In Re the Marriage of Stevens
2011 MT 106
| Mont. | 2011Background
- Stevens petitioned for dissolution; they have three minor children and separated in 2008 after marriage in 2004.
- Randy began a relationship with Samantha and resides with her and their child; trial occurred with bench ruling.
- District Court adopted a permanent parenting plan, set child support at $1,188/month, and awarded Tiffany $2,500 in attorney fees.
- Randy’s objections focused on overtime income, health insurance costs, and days with children; Tiffany opposed some arguments.
- Court found Randy’s schedule 84 hours biweekly, awarded health insurance costs to Tiffany while ordering Randy to maintain coverage.
- We reverse in part and remand for recalculation of child support consistent with this opinion.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Did the district court err in Randy's child support calculation? | Stevens contends overtime and insurance issues; days calculation inaccurate. | Stevens argues overtime mischaracterized; health insurance costs should not be credited. | Remand for recalculation; overtime inclusion upheld; health insurance costs credit required. |
| Did the district court err by ordering Randy to reimburse Tiffany's attorney fees? | Stevens argues fees not shown as reasonable or supported by a hearing. | Harkin-Dennison framework supports award based on financial resources and evidence. | Award affirmed; hearing not required given record and acquiescence. |
Key Cases Cited
- In re Marriage of Harkin, 999 P.2d 969 (Mont. 2000) (attorney fees must be reasonable and based on competent evidence)
- In re Marriage of Dennison, 132 P.3d 535 (Mont. 2006) (abuse of discretion standard for fee awards)
- In re Marriage of Frick, 359 Mont. 296 (Mont. 2011) (credit for health insurance costs when provided; trial record matters)
- In re Marriage of Hogstad, 914 P.2d 584 (Mont. 1996) (court not to credit insurance costs if not incurred at trial)
- In re Marriage of Williams, 360 Mont. 46 (Mont. 2011) (actual income and fair reflection of resources for support)
