In Re the Cecilia Kincaid Gift Trust for George
2012 MT 119
Mont.2012Background
- Gloria LaMott and Glenn Kincaid, Jr. appeal a September 6, 2011 district court order distributing Cecilia Kincaid Gift Trust for George proceeds.
- Trust established December 1976; grantor Cecilia Kincaid Bates; co-trustees George W. Kincaid and Richard E. Peterson; George was sole lifetime beneficiary.
- George died October 15, 2009 intestate; remaining trust funds were to be distributed to George’s living descendants per Article XIII, § 3.
- Jennifer Fazio (born after trust, biologically George’s child, later adopted) objected to a proposed distribution that would exclude her.
- District Court held Jennifer was a living descendant entitled to distribution; trustees appeal the interpretation of “descendant” defined in the trust.
- Trust instrument defines “descendants” to include adopted children as descendants of their adoptive parents and not of the natural parent.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether Jennifer Fazio is a “descendant” of George under the Trust | Fazio should be included as a descendant under Art. XIII, §3 | Adopted child language makes Jennifer a descendant of her adoptive parents, not George | Jennifer is not a descendant of George under the Trust |
Key Cases Cited
- In re: Marjorie Q. Ward Revocable Trust, 2011 MT 308 (Mont. 2011) (plain language governs; construes trust words in ordinary sense)
- Mary J. Baker Revocable Trust v. Cenex Harvest States, Coops., Inc., 338 Mont. 41, 164 P.3d 851 (Mont. 2007) (ambiguous terms may admit extrinsic evidence under § 1-4-101, MCA)
- In re: The Charles M. Bair Family Trust, 343 Mont. 138, 183 P.3d 61 (Mont. 2008) (plain language control; interpretation limited to words used)
