History
  • No items yet
midpage
In Re the Cecilia Kincaid Gift Trust for George
2012 MT 119
Mont.
2012
Read the full case

Background

  • Gloria LaMott and Glenn Kincaid, Jr. appeal a September 6, 2011 district court order distributing Cecilia Kincaid Gift Trust for George proceeds.
  • Trust established December 1976; grantor Cecilia Kincaid Bates; co-trustees George W. Kincaid and Richard E. Peterson; George was sole lifetime beneficiary.
  • George died October 15, 2009 intestate; remaining trust funds were to be distributed to George’s living descendants per Article XIII, § 3.
  • Jennifer Fazio (born after trust, biologically George’s child, later adopted) objected to a proposed distribution that would exclude her.
  • District Court held Jennifer was a living descendant entitled to distribution; trustees appeal the interpretation of “descendant” defined in the trust.
  • Trust instrument defines “descendants” to include adopted children as descendants of their adoptive parents and not of the natural parent.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether Jennifer Fazio is a “descendant” of George under the Trust Fazio should be included as a descendant under Art. XIII, §3 Adopted child language makes Jennifer a descendant of her adoptive parents, not George Jennifer is not a descendant of George under the Trust

Key Cases Cited

  • In re: Marjorie Q. Ward Revocable Trust, 2011 MT 308 (Mont. 2011) (plain language governs; construes trust words in ordinary sense)
  • Mary J. Baker Revocable Trust v. Cenex Harvest States, Coops., Inc., 338 Mont. 41, 164 P.3d 851 (Mont. 2007) (ambiguous terms may admit extrinsic evidence under § 1-4-101, MCA)
  • In re: The Charles M. Bair Family Trust, 343 Mont. 138, 183 P.3d 61 (Mont. 2008) (plain language control; interpretation limited to words used)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: In Re the Cecilia Kincaid Gift Trust for George
Court Name: Montana Supreme Court
Date Published: May 29, 2012
Citation: 2012 MT 119
Docket Number: DA 11-0695
Court Abbreviation: Mont.