Slip Opinion
S.D.N.Y.Oct 12, 2016Background
- This is a Report & Recommendation in Hoglan v. Islamic Republic of Iran, part of the MDL arising from the 9/11 attacks; Judge Maas compiled prior Havlish/Ashton findings into the record and Judge Daniels entered default judgments on liability against Iranian defendants.
- Plaintiffs: estates of 15 decedents and 278 individual family members; most decedents were U.S. nationals; two estates (Rowe, Shefi) involved non-U.S. national decedents whose claims are partly reserved for later consideration.
- Estate claims: economic losses (lost wages/benefits, household services, etc.) and pain-and-suffering for decedents’ conscious pain before death. A forensic economist’s calculations (Dr. Stan V. Smith) were adopted for economic losses.
- Individual claims: solatium (mental anguish, bereavement, loss of society) for immediate family members and additional “functional equivalent” relatives; plaintiffs categorized claimants into Category A (immediate family), B, and C (functional equivalents).
- R&R recommendations: award partial default judgment against Iran totaling $1,759,715,035 to 13 estates and 190 individual plaintiffs (economic damages + pain-and-suffering + solatium); award prejudgment interest on pain/solatium at 4.96% compounded annually from 9/11/2001; punitive damages denied without prejudice for supplemental briefing.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability (default) | Iran is liable under FSIA §1605A for supporting Al Qaeda/terrorism causing 9/11 injuries | Iran defaulted; liability previously entered in Hoglan/Havlish | Liability already entered by Judge Daniels; R&R proceeds to damages calculation |
| Economic damages for estates | Adopt Dr. Smith’s lost-wage and replacement-service calculations based on working to age 67 and standard growth/discount assumptions | (No contested submission due to default) | Court adopts Dr. Smith’s economic awards for all U.S.-national decedent estates (excluding Rowe/Shefi) totaling $469,465,035 |
| Solatium eligibility & amounts | Apply Heiser/Heiser-derived Havlish framework increasing Heiser baseline for 9/11: spouse $12.5M; parent/child $8.5M; sibling $4.25M; include U.S.-national children of non-U.S. decedent Shefi | (Defendant defaulted; jurisdictional limit argument could be that victim or claimant must be U.S. national) | Court adopts Judge Maas’s enhanced solatium scale for 188 Category A U.S.-national immediate relatives plus two U.S.-national Shefi children, totaling $1,264,250,000; other Category B/C and non-U.S. immediate relatives deferred |
| Punitive damages methodology | Plaintiffs rely on Flatow/Valore/Murphy line applying multiplier (3.44) of compensatory damages or Flatow method tying punishments to state terrorism financing | (Iran defaulted; no substantive contest) | Court rejects adoption of 3.44 multiplier as unpersuasive here, denies punitive damages without prejudice and invites supplemental briefing (including evidence of Iran’s terrorism financing if Flatow method urged) |
| Prejudgment interest rate for pain/solatium | Seek NY CPLR 9% for NY-based claims; 4.96% average prime rate for non-NY claims per Havlish | (No substantive contest) | Court holds NY statutory rate inapplicable to solatium/pain-and-suffering; awards prejudgment interest at 4.96% (avg. Fed Reserve prime rate used in Havlish) compounded annually from 9/11/2001 |
Key Cases Cited
- Mastrantuono v. United States, 163 F. Supp. 2d 244 (S.D.N.Y. 2001) (standard of reasonableness for pain-and-suffering awards)
- Heiser v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 466 F. Supp. 2d 229 (D.D.C. 2006) (baseline solatium framework adopted in later FSIA terrorism awards)
- Belkin v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 667 F. Supp. 2d 8 (D.D.C. 2009) (definition of solatium under §1605A)
- Philip Morris USA v. Williams, 549 U.S. 346 (U.S. 2007) (limits punitive damages to harms to parties before the court)
- Frontera Res. Azerbaijan Corp. v. State Oil Co. of Azerbaijan Republic, 582 F.3d 393 (2d Cir. 2009) (foreign sovereigns not "persons" for certain constitutional protections)
- Estate of Brand v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 831 F. Supp. 2d 150 (D.D.C. 2011) (Flatow/Valore methodology applied to set punitive damages)
- Murphy v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 740 F. Supp. 2d 51 (D.D.C. 2010) (applying multiplier from prior Flatow/Valore-based calculations)
- Valore v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 700 F. Supp. 2d 52 (D.D.C. 2010) (Flatow-based calculation relating punitive award to state financing levels)
- Flatow v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 999 F. Supp. 1 (D.D.C. 1998) (pioneering punitive-damage approach in FSIA terrorism cases)
- Opati v. Republic of Sudan, 60 F. Supp. 3d 68 (D.D.C. 2014) (discussion of prejudgment interest and treatment of solatium/pain awards)