midpage
Slip Opinion
S.D.N.Y.
Oct 12, 2016

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • This is a Report & Recommendation in Hoglan v. Islamic Republic of Iran, part of the MDL arising from the 9/11 attacks; Judge Maas compiled prior Havlish/Ashton findings into the record and Judge Daniels entered default judgments on liability against Iranian defendants.
  • Plaintiffs: estates of 15 decedents and 278 individual family members; most decedents were U.S. nationals; two estates (Rowe, Shefi) involved non-U.S. national decedents whose claims are partly reserved for later consideration.
  • Estate claims: economic losses (lost wages/benefits, household services, etc.) and pain-and-suffering for decedents’ conscious pain before death. A forensic economist’s calculations (Dr. Stan V. Smith) were adopted for economic losses.
  • Individual claims: solatium (mental anguish, bereavement, loss of society) for immediate family members and additional “functional equivalent” relatives; plaintiffs categorized claimants into Category A (immediate family), B, and C (functional equivalents).
  • R&R recommendations: award partial default judgment against Iran totaling $1,759,715,035 to 13 estates and 190 individual plaintiffs (economic damages + pain-and-suffering + solatium); award prejudgment interest on pain/solatium at 4.96% compounded annually from 9/11/2001; punitive damages denied without prejudice for supplemental briefing.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Liability (default) Iran is liable under FSIA §1605A for supporting Al Qaeda/terrorism causing 9/11 injuries Iran defaulted; liability previously entered in Hoglan/Havlish Liability already entered by Judge Daniels; R&R proceeds to damages calculation
Economic damages for estates Adopt Dr. Smith’s lost-wage and replacement-service calculations based on working to age 67 and standard growth/discount assumptions (No contested submission due to default) Court adopts Dr. Smith’s economic awards for all U.S.-national decedent estates (excluding Rowe/Shefi) totaling $469,465,035
Solatium eligibility & amounts Apply Heiser/Heiser-derived Havlish framework increasing Heiser baseline for 9/11: spouse $12.5M; parent/child $8.5M; sibling $4.25M; include U.S.-national children of non-U.S. decedent Shefi (Defendant defaulted; jurisdictional limit argument could be that victim or claimant must be U.S. national) Court adopts Judge Maas’s enhanced solatium scale for 188 Category A U.S.-national immediate relatives plus two U.S.-national Shefi children, totaling $1,264,250,000; other Category B/C and non-U.S. immediate relatives deferred
Punitive damages methodology Plaintiffs rely on Flatow/Valore/Murphy line applying multiplier (3.44) of compensatory damages or Flatow method tying punishments to state terrorism financing (Iran defaulted; no substantive contest) Court rejects adoption of 3.44 multiplier as unpersuasive here, denies punitive damages without prejudice and invites supplemental briefing (including evidence of Iran’s terrorism financing if Flatow method urged)
Prejudgment interest rate for pain/solatium Seek NY CPLR 9% for NY-based claims; 4.96% average prime rate for non-NY claims per Havlish (No substantive contest) Court holds NY statutory rate inapplicable to solatium/pain-and-suffering; awards prejudgment interest at 4.96% (avg. Fed Reserve prime rate used in Havlish) compounded annually from 9/11/2001

Key Cases Cited

  • Mastrantuono v. United States, 163 F. Supp. 2d 244 (S.D.N.Y. 2001) (standard of reasonableness for pain-and-suffering awards)
  • Heiser v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 466 F. Supp. 2d 229 (D.D.C. 2006) (baseline solatium framework adopted in later FSIA terrorism awards)
  • Belkin v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 667 F. Supp. 2d 8 (D.D.C. 2009) (definition of solatium under §1605A)
  • Philip Morris USA v. Williams, 549 U.S. 346 (U.S. 2007) (limits punitive damages to harms to parties before the court)
  • Frontera Res. Azerbaijan Corp. v. State Oil Co. of Azerbaijan Republic, 582 F.3d 393 (2d Cir. 2009) (foreign sovereigns not "persons" for certain constitutional protections)
  • Estate of Brand v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 831 F. Supp. 2d 150 (D.D.C. 2011) (Flatow/Valore methodology applied to set punitive damages)
  • Murphy v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 740 F. Supp. 2d 51 (D.D.C. 2010) (applying multiplier from prior Flatow/Valore-based calculations)
  • Valore v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 700 F. Supp. 2d 52 (D.D.C. 2010) (Flatow-based calculation relating punitive award to state financing levels)
  • Flatow v. Islamic Republic of Iran, 999 F. Supp. 1 (D.D.C. 1998) (pioneering punitive-damage approach in FSIA terrorism cases)
  • Opati v. Republic of Sudan, 60 F. Supp. 3d 68 (D.D.C. 2014) (discussion of prejudgment interest and treatment of solatium/pain awards)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: In Re: Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001
Court Name: District Court, S.D. New York
Date Published: Oct 12, 2016
Citation: 1:03-md-01570
Docket Number: 1:03-md-01570
Court Abbreviation: S.D.N.Y.
Log In