In re T.J.W.
2014 Ohio 4419
Ohio Ct. App.2014Background
- Three children of Channe Fleischer and Adrian Wolfe—T.J.W. (born 2011), N.A.W. (born 2012), and N.M.W. (born 2012)—were involved with JCDJFS after twins tested positive for drugs at birth.
- Mother admitted snorting pills before birth that may have been laced with heroin, prompting filing of dependency/abuse-neglect complaints on January 3, 2013.
- JCDJFS sought adjudications of abused/neglected/dependent for the twins and dependency for T.J.W., plus temporary custody pending disposition.
- Ex parte custody was granted at an informal shelter care hearing on January 3, 2013.
- Adjudicatory hearing on February 21, 2013 resulted in rulings that T.J.W. was dependent and the twins were abused/neglected/dependent, with temporary custody to JCDJFS.
- Disposition hearing (April 1, 2013) and Juvenile Court adoption (April 24, 2013) granted temporary custody to JCDJFS; no objections were filed by either parent.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waiver and plain error for lack of objections | Wolfe argued there was error in the magistrate's findings. | No objections were timely raised, preserving waiver. | Waived; no plain error found. |
Key Cases Cited
- Fearer v. Humility of Mary Health Partners, 2008-Ohio-1181 (7th Dist. 2008) (waiver and plain error considerations)
- Goldfuss v. Davidson, 79 Ohio St.3d 116 (1997) (plain error standard)
- In re I.T.A. and A.A., 2012-Ohio-1689 (7th Dist. 2012) (waiver rule and application)
- Schade v. Carnegie Body Co., 70 Ohio St.2d 207 (1982) (standard for error preservation)
- In re J.C., 2013-Ohio-2819 (11th Dist. 2013) (plain error and review standard)
- State v. Barnes, 2002-Ohio-68 (Ohio Supreme Court 2002) (definition of plain error)
