midpage
761 S.E.2d 231
S.C.
2014

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Appellant (age 16) was charged with possession of marijuana; family court adjudicated him delinquent after an evidentiary hearing and imposed rehabilitative sanctions.
  • At the adjudicatory hearing Appellant moved for a jury trial under the U.S. and South Carolina Constitutions; the family court denied the motion.
  • Facts at hearing: officer pursued Appellant, Appellant discarded items, baggies with marijuana were recovered near where items were discarded; Appellant denied knowledge.
  • Appellant appealed the denial of a jury trial; the appeal was certified to the Supreme Court of South Carolina.
  • The Children’s Code and Family Court Rules provide that juvenile hearings are conducted by the court without a jury and treat adjudications as noncriminal, rehabilitative proceedings.

Issues

Issue Appellant's Argument State's Argument Held
Whether juveniles have a federal constitutional right to a jury trial in family court delinquency proceedings McKeiver does not preclude Appellant; he is entitled to a jury under the U.S. Constitution McKeiver controls; no federal right to jury in juvenile adjudications No federal right; statute and rule constitutional under federal law
Whether Article I, § 14 of the S.C. Constitution guarantees a jury trial in family court juvenile adjudications The phrase “any person charged with an offense” includes juveniles and secures a jury right Juvenile adjudication is unlike 1868 criminal prosecutions; right limited to cases triable by jury in 1868 or of like nature No state constitutional right; juvenile adjudication not of like nature to 1868 criminal prosecutions

Key Cases Cited

  • McKeiver v. Pennsylvania, 403 U.S. 528 (U.S. 1971) (plurality: no federal constitutional right to jury trial in juvenile adjudications)
  • Mims Amusement Co. v. S.C. Law Enforcement Div., 366 S.C. 141 (S.C. 2005) (state jury-right analysis tied to rights existing at constitution adoption and to later actions of like nature)
  • In re Skinner, 272 S.C. 135 (S.C. 1978) (juvenile process aims to avoid stigma of criminal conviction)
  • City Council of Anderson v. O’Donnell, 29 S.C. 355 (S.C. 1888) (jury right to be read in light of law existing at constitution adoption)
  • State v. Harrison, 402 S.C. 288 (S.C. 2013) (standard of review for constitutional challenges to statutes)
  • State v. Coleman, 54 S.C. 162 (S.C. 1899) (examples of juveniles being criminally prosecuted and tried by jury under common law)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: In re Stephen W.
Court Name: Supreme Court of South Carolina
Date Published: Jul 16, 2014
Citations: 761 S.E.2d 231; 409 S.C. 73; 2014 WL 3461568; 2014 S.C. LEXIS 260; Appellate Case No. 2012-213481; No. 27413
Docket Number: Appellate Case No. 2012-213481; No. 27413
Court Abbreviation: S.C.
Log In