2023 Ohio 1663
Ohio Ct. App.2023Background
- Jan. 13–14, 2021: Mother was found disoriented/undressed in public with infant S.S.; police delivered S.S. to Lucas County Children Services (LCCS) and the juvenile court awarded LCCS interim temporary custody.
- Case plan aimed at reunification required mental‑health assessment, domestic‑violence counseling, and parenting classes; mother moved to Connecticut, had sporadic contact, missed many visits, and was removed from the plan in Dec. 2021.
- S.S. was placed with foster parents, received medical/developmental care (including speech therapy), and became bonded to the foster family, who wished to adopt him.
- LCCS filed for permanent custody April 18, 2022; the GAL recommended permanent custody; relatives proposed as placements were investigated and found unsuitable or unavailable.
- Juvenile court granted LCCS permanent custody Aug. 22, 2022, finding S.S. had been in agency custody over 12 months, parents had abandoned or failed to remedy conditions, and permanent custody was in the child’s best interest.
- Mother appealed, raising two assignments: (1) LCCS failed to investigate kinship placement (maternal great‑grandmother); (2) the GAL failed to perform required independent investigation.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether LCCS failed to make reasonable efforts/investigate maternal great‑grandmother as a kinship placement | Mother: LCCS did not properly investigate or consider maternal great‑grandmother who requested placement/adoption | LCCS: agency made intensive efforts to locate appropriate kin, relatives were unsuitable or unavailable, great‑grandmother expressed adoption interest late and legal custody was inappropriate while motion pending | Court: Claim lacks merit; agency made reasonable/intensive efforts and best‑interest finding supported; juvenile court not required to prefer relatives |
| Whether the GAL failed to conduct an independent investigation per Sup.R. 48 | Mother: GAL merely observed virtual visits and "rubber‑stamped" LCCS recommendations, failing to contact relevant persons or investigate placements | LCCS/GAL: mother did not challenge GAL compliance at trial; GAL interviewed multiple parties, visited the child, and prepared a detailed report; Sup.R. 48 is supervisory | Court: GAL complied with duties; mother’s challenge fails; assignment not well‑taken |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Thompkins, 78 Ohio St.3d 380 (Ohio 1997) (describing the manifest‑weight standard for appellate review)
- In re Schaefer, 111 Ohio St.3d 498 (Ohio 2006) (discussing best‑interest considerations in juvenile permanency decisions)