In re Nale Estate
290 Mich. App. 704
| Mich. Ct. App. | 2010Background
- Respondent was convicted of voluntary manslaughter in the death of her husband in 2007 and sentenced to 34 to 180 months.
- Petitioner Julia Cook, successor personal representative, petitioned probate court to forfeit and revoke respondent’s benefits under MCL 700.2803.
- Probate court held that respondent forfeited all benefits because of felonious and intentional killing.
- Respondent argued manslaughter is not an 'intentional killing' under MCL 700.2803 and thus she could receive estate benefits.
- This Court reviews the legal interpretation of MCL 700.2803 de novo; factual posture is on the record.
- Statutory text and common-law slayer rule are used to determine whether voluntary manslaughter falls within 'feloniously and intentionally' killing.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Does MCL 700.2803 apply to voluntary manslaughter? | Cook argues manslaughter is not 'intentional killing'. | Nale contends statute covers intentional killings, including manslaughter. | Yes; statute applies to voluntary manslaughter. |
| Is voluntary manslaughter an 'intentional killing' for purposes of the slayer rule? | Manslaughter lacks intent to kill. | Voluntary manslaughter is an intentional killing under common law. | Voluntary manslaughter is an intentional killing, triggering forfeiture. |
Key Cases Cited
- Garwols v Bankers Trust Co, 251 Mich 420 (1930) (slayer rule extends to manslaughter)
- People v Mendoza, 468 Mich 527 (2003) (defines voluntary manslaughter; intentional killing context)
- People v Townes, 391 Mich 578 (1974) (voluntary manslaughter elements; provocation)
- People v Pouncey, 437 Mich 382 (1991) (voluntary vs involuntary manslaughter elements)
- People v Delaughter, 124 Mich App 356 (1983) (essential element of intent to kill or cause serious harm)
- People v Hess, 214 Mich App 33 (1995) (comparison of murder and voluntary manslaughter regarding 'intentional')
- Budwit v Herr, 339 Mich 265 (1954) (early articulation of slayer rule and common-law approach)
