255 N.C. App. 296
N.C. Ct. App.2017Background
- DSS filed juvenile petition (May 1, 2015) alleging Luke was abused, neglected, and dependent; DSS obtained and kept nonsecure custody.
- Trial court adjudicated Luke abused/neglected/dependent (Mar 3, 2016), noting parents had pending felony child abuse charges, prior relinquishments of parental rights to other children, and domestic violence incidents; reunification efforts ceased.
- Permanency plan set to adoption with concurrent guardianship; respondent (father) later convicted of felony child abuse and sentenced to 60–84 months.
- DSS filed petition to terminate parental rights (Aug 1, 2016; amended Aug 22, 2016) alleging multiple grounds including abuse, neglect, abandonment, failure to correct conditions, failure to pay, and felony assault causing serious injury.
- Trial court terminated respondent’s parental rights (Nov 28, 2016); respondent appealed solely arguing the court failed to address potential applicability of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA).
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument (DSS) | Defendant's Argument (Respondent) | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether trial court erred by not addressing ICWA applicability | DSS maintained ICWA did not apply and court had previously found ICWA inapplicable in juvenile orders | Respondent argued the court failed to determine whether Luke was a member of a Native American tribe and thus ICWA should have been considered | Court held respondent failed to preserve the issue at trial and did not meet burden to show ICWA applied; affirmed termination |
Key Cases Cited
- In re A.D.L., 169 N.C. App. 701 (2005) (explains ICWA purpose and two-step prerequisite inquiry)
- In re C.P., 181 N.C. App. 698 (2007) (places burden on party invoking ICWA to show applicability)
- In re Williams, 149 N.C. App. 951 (2002) (equivocal testimony alone is insufficient to meet ICWA burden)
- In re A.R., 227 N.C. App. 518 (2013) (mere belief a child is an Indian child does not meet burden; remand appropriate when investigation/results unclear)
