midpage
76 Cal.App.5th 732
Cal. Ct. App.
2022
Read the full case

Background

  • CFS opened a dependency investigation in Jan 2019 after suspected nonaccidental trauma; parents and relatives reported possible Cherokee, Choctaw, and Blackfeet ancestry and provided names and contact information.
  • CFS sent some ICWA notices (to Blackfeet and some Cherokee tribes) but omitted key ancestral/biographical details and did not notify any federally recognized Choctaw tribes.
  • Parents and several relatives identified tribal connections at hearings and on ICWA-020 forms; the record shows no meaningful follow-up interviews with listed relatives or comprehensive tribe/BIA contacts.
  • Juvenile court twice found ICWA did not apply and later terminated parental rights at the § 366.26 hearing.
  • On appeal CFS conceded it failed to satisfy the statutory duty of further inquiry under Welfare & Institutions Code § 224.2.
  • The Court of Appeal conditionally reversed the termination orders and remanded with directions that CFS complete the required inquiry and notices and the court determine whether ICWA applies.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Did parents’ assertions of Cherokee/Choctaw/Blackfeet ancestry trigger the duty of further inquiry under § 224.2(e)? CFS (respondent) effectively conceded it failed to satisfy any duty of further inquiry. Parents argued those assertions and provided contacts created "reason to believe" and required further inquiry. Court: Affirmative — the parents’ statements and provided family info triggered the duty of further inquiry; CFS failed to comply.
Were the ICWA notices adequate when they omitted ancestor details and did not include Choctaw tribes? CFS had sent some notices but omitted identifying ancestor info and failed to notify all potentially relevant tribes. Parents argued notices were incomplete and insufficient to allow tribes to determine membership eligibility. Court: Notices were inadequate; omission of ancestral data and failure to contact all likely tribes violated ICWA duties.
Could the juvenile court properly find ICWA inapplicable without requiring CFS to report or testify about its inquiry? The court made a finding ICWA did not apply. Parents argued the court erred by accepting an unsupported finding without requiring proof of adequate inquiry/notice. Court: Error — the court must obtain a report or have the responsible person testify about the inquiry and notices before finding ICWA inapplicable.
Remedy: Must the termination orders be reversed/remanded? CFS conceded error and supported remand for ICWA compliance. Parents sought reversal of termination orders and remand for proper ICWA process. Court: Conditionally reversed § 366.26 orders and remanded. If court later finds ICWA does not apply, termination orders may be reinstated; if ICWA applies, proceed under ICWA.

Key Cases Cited

  • In re Isaiah W., 1 Cal.5th 1 (2016) (describing ICWA's purpose and need for early, swift inquiry)
  • In re W.B., 55 Cal.4th 30 (2012) (ICWA's purpose and procedural protections)
  • In re T.G., 58 Cal.App.5th 275 (2020) (duty to ask involved persons about Indian status; agency duty to contact tribes)
  • In re S.R., 64 Cal.App.5th 303 (2021) (failure to satisfy duty of further inquiry requires reversal)
  • In re Benjamin M., 70 Cal.App.5th 735 (2021) (on importance of initial/further ICWA inquiry)
  • In re L.S., 230 Cal.App.4th 1183 (2014) (failure to comply with notice provisions is prejudicial error requiring reversal)
  • In re B.H., 241 Cal.App.4th 603 (2015) (criticism of recurring ICWA noncompliance appeals)
  • In re D.F., 55 Cal.App.5th 558 (2020) (tribes identify information necessary for membership determination)
  • In re K.R., 20 Cal.App.5th 701 (2018) (agency must make meaningful efforts to locate and interview extended family)
  • In re Francisco W., 139 Cal.App.4th 695 (2006) (best practices for including ancestor information in ICWA notices)
  • Santa Clara Pueblo v. Martinez, 436 U.S. 49 (1978) (tribes are the final arbiter of their membership)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: In re K.T.
Court Name: California Court of Appeal
Date Published: Mar 23, 2022
Citations: 76 Cal.App.5th 732; 291 Cal.Rptr.3d 678; E077791
Docket Number: E077791
Court Abbreviation: Cal. Ct. App.
Log In