76 Cal.App.5th 732
Cal. Ct. App.2022Background
- CFS opened a dependency investigation in Jan 2019 after suspected nonaccidental trauma; parents and relatives reported possible Cherokee, Choctaw, and Blackfeet ancestry and provided names and contact information.
- CFS sent some ICWA notices (to Blackfeet and some Cherokee tribes) but omitted key ancestral/biographical details and did not notify any federally recognized Choctaw tribes.
- Parents and several relatives identified tribal connections at hearings and on ICWA-020 forms; the record shows no meaningful follow-up interviews with listed relatives or comprehensive tribe/BIA contacts.
- Juvenile court twice found ICWA did not apply and later terminated parental rights at the § 366.26 hearing.
- On appeal CFS conceded it failed to satisfy the statutory duty of further inquiry under Welfare & Institutions Code § 224.2.
- The Court of Appeal conditionally reversed the termination orders and remanded with directions that CFS complete the required inquiry and notices and the court determine whether ICWA applies.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Did parents’ assertions of Cherokee/Choctaw/Blackfeet ancestry trigger the duty of further inquiry under § 224.2(e)? | CFS (respondent) effectively conceded it failed to satisfy any duty of further inquiry. | Parents argued those assertions and provided contacts created "reason to believe" and required further inquiry. | Court: Affirmative — the parents’ statements and provided family info triggered the duty of further inquiry; CFS failed to comply. |
| Were the ICWA notices adequate when they omitted ancestor details and did not include Choctaw tribes? | CFS had sent some notices but omitted identifying ancestor info and failed to notify all potentially relevant tribes. | Parents argued notices were incomplete and insufficient to allow tribes to determine membership eligibility. | Court: Notices were inadequate; omission of ancestral data and failure to contact all likely tribes violated ICWA duties. |
| Could the juvenile court properly find ICWA inapplicable without requiring CFS to report or testify about its inquiry? | The court made a finding ICWA did not apply. | Parents argued the court erred by accepting an unsupported finding without requiring proof of adequate inquiry/notice. | Court: Error — the court must obtain a report or have the responsible person testify about the inquiry and notices before finding ICWA inapplicable. |
| Remedy: Must the termination orders be reversed/remanded? | CFS conceded error and supported remand for ICWA compliance. | Parents sought reversal of termination orders and remand for proper ICWA process. | Court: Conditionally reversed § 366.26 orders and remanded. If court later finds ICWA does not apply, termination orders may be reinstated; if ICWA applies, proceed under ICWA. |
Key Cases Cited
- In re Isaiah W., 1 Cal.5th 1 (2016) (describing ICWA's purpose and need for early, swift inquiry)
- In re W.B., 55 Cal.4th 30 (2012) (ICWA's purpose and procedural protections)
- In re T.G., 58 Cal.App.5th 275 (2020) (duty to ask involved persons about Indian status; agency duty to contact tribes)
- In re S.R., 64 Cal.App.5th 303 (2021) (failure to satisfy duty of further inquiry requires reversal)
- In re Benjamin M., 70 Cal.App.5th 735 (2021) (on importance of initial/further ICWA inquiry)
- In re L.S., 230 Cal.App.4th 1183 (2014) (failure to comply with notice provisions is prejudicial error requiring reversal)
- In re B.H., 241 Cal.App.4th 603 (2015) (criticism of recurring ICWA noncompliance appeals)
- In re D.F., 55 Cal.App.5th 558 (2020) (tribes identify information necessary for membership determination)
- In re K.R., 20 Cal.App.5th 701 (2018) (agency must make meaningful efforts to locate and interview extended family)
- In re Francisco W., 139 Cal.App.4th 695 (2006) (best practices for including ancestor information in ICWA notices)
- Santa Clara Pueblo v. Martinez, 436 U.S. 49 (1978) (tribes are the final arbiter of their membership)