316 Neb. 600
Neb.2024Background
- Michael A. Hessler, decedent, created a trust (the "Michael Hessler Living Trust") for his children.
- In 2017, he amended the trust to leave his residence "outright" to his girlfriend, Lori J. Miller, if she lived there at the time of his death, and left the residuary to his three children.
- Upon Hessler's death, the successor trustee registered the trust in Scotts Bluff County, conveyed the house to Miller, and allocated all inheritance tax to the trust's residuary.
- The children argued inheritance taxes attributable to Miller’s distribution (taxed at a higher rate due to her non-marital status) should come from her share, not from the residuary trust property.
- The county court ruled the trust clearly directed that such taxes be paid "from this trust," not separately apportioning them.
- The children appealed, raising issues of venue, evidentiary rulings, and proper apportionment of inheritance taxes.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Venue transfer to Scotts Bluff County | Venue should be in Lancaster County, where the real estate and relevant parties were located | Venue proper in Scotts Bluff County, where the trust is registered and trustee resides | Transfer of venue was proper under statute and not an abuse of discretion |
| Admission of extrinsic evidence (attorney affidavit) | Court erred by admitting parol evidence to interpret the trust, as the trust was unambiguous | The affidavit merely corroborated the decedent’s clear written intent | No reversible error; ruling based on trust language, not affidavit |
| Apportionment of inheritance taxes | Inheritance tax on Miller’s share should be paid from her distribution, not from the trust's residuary property for the children | Trust expressly directed payment of all inheritance taxes from the trust before distributions | Trust language clear; taxes paid from trust as directed, not apportioned pro rata |
Key Cases Cited
- In re Estate of Larson, 311 Neb. 352 (inheritance tax is imposed on beneficiaries; default is statutory apportionment unless the testamentary instrument clearly directs otherwise)
- In re Estate of Shell, 290 Neb. 791 (language directing payment of estate and inheritance taxes from the estate exonerates beneficiaries from personal liability for such taxes)
- In re Hessler Living Trust, 313 Neb. 607 (prior related appeal regarding this trust's administration and finality/jurisdiction)
