In re Haley K.
163 N.H. 247
N.H.2012Background
- Haley born August 2007; father incarcerated for theft in May 2009, leaving Haley with caregiver adults.
- DCYF filed a neglect petition in June 2009 alleging Haley was neglected due to lack of proper care/control.
- An adjudicatory hearing led to a consent order in which Haley was found neglected.
- July 2010 DCYF petitions to terminate parental rights; Haley's mother surrendered.
- Trial court found beyond reasonable doubt that father failed to correct neglect within twelve months despite reasonable DCYF efforts; Haley remained in foster care.
- Court affirmed termination, holding incarceration and lack of adequate provisions for Haley while incarcerated contributed to neglect, and that termination was appropriate under RSA 170-C:5.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether DCYF provided reasonable services to assist reunification | State argues services were reasonable under constraints | Conboy argues services were insufficient due to incarceration | Yes; DCYF provided reasonable services |
| Whether incarceration can be considered in assessing correction of neglect | State treats incarceration as relevant per statute | Conboy argues incarceration should not omit neglect analysis | Incarceration is a permissible factor in neglect analysis |
| Whether termination was proper under RSA 170-C:5 grounds | State sought termination for failure to correct within twelve months | Conboy contends lack of corrective effort due to custody circumstances | Affirmed; termination upheld |
Key Cases Cited
- In re Juvenile 2006-674, 156 N.H. 1 (N.H. 2007) (standard for termination proof beyond a reasonable doubt; proper grounds)
- In re Juvenile 2006-833, 156 N.H. 482 (N.H. 2007) (reasonable services standard; agency limitations)
- In re Tricia H., 126 N.H. 418 (N.H. 1985) (compliance with orders as non-dispositive to termination)
- In re Adam M., 148 N.H. 83 (N.H. 2002) (parental responsibilities during incarceration)
- Appeal of Keelin B., 162 N.H. 38 (N.H. 2011) (statutory interpretation of care and services)
