midpage
442 B.R. 173
Bankr. D. Mass.
2010
Read the full case

Background

  • Debtor Jorge H. Darosa filed for bankruptcy in the District of Massachusetts; U.S. Bank National Association seeks relief from the automatic stay to foreclose its mortgage on property in Lowell, MA.
  • Bank requested relief under 11 U.S.C. §362(d)(1) (for cause, including lack of adequate protection) or §362(d)(2) (lack of equity and not necessary to reorganization).
  • Bank bore the burden to prove lack of equity under §362(g); local rule requires stating fair market value and liquidation value with supporting appraisals.
  • Bank initially valued the Lowell property by the tax assessor’s valuation, leading the court to deny relief without prejudice for lack of acceptable valuation basis.
  • At a reconsideration hearing, the bank presented a drive-by property evaluation valuing the property at $205,000; the bank owed over $360,000.
  • The court granted relief from stay based on the drive-by valuation, while clarifying that tax assessor valuations are not an acceptable, standalone basis for determining value under §362(d).

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
May tax assessor value establish lack of equity? Bank argues tax assessment can reflect value for lack of equity. Darosa contends tax assessments are not reliable current value for relief from stay. Tax assessor valuations are not acceptable alone to prove lack of equity.
Is a drive-by valuation reliable enough to establish lack of equity? Bank offers drive-by valuation showing no equity. Debtor and court require persuasive, case-specific reliability beyond Internet or public data. Drive-by appraisal can establish lack of equity; court accepts $205,000 value as credible for relief from stay.
Can a debtor's scheduled value support a lack of equity finding? Scheduled value admitted as debtor’s valuation in proceedings. Court should require reliable current valuation rather than solely relying on schedules. The scheduled value may support lack of equity if reliable, but in this case the court relies on the drive-by valuation for relief.

Key Cases Cited

  • Shane v. Shane, 891 F.2d 976 (1st Cir. 1989) (owner competent to testify about value of own property)
  • Robinson v. Watts Detective Agency, Inc., 685 F.2d 729 (1st Cir. 1982) (testimony about value by owner admissible)
  • In re Healthco Intern., Inc., 257 B.R. 379 (Bankr. D. Mass. 2001) (tax assessments not sole basis for credibility in value disputes)
  • U.S. v. 10,031.98 Acres of Land, More or Less, Situate in Las Animas County, Colo., 850 F.2d 634 (10th Cir. 1988) (valorization and credibility of land valuations considerations)
  • Carlucci, 2010 WL 3895500 (Bankr. D. N.H. 2010) (tax assessments may be used as a factor in valuation but not sole basis)
  • Justice v. Pennzoil Co., 598 F.2d 1339 (4th Cir. 1979) (valuation considerations in property disputes)
  • Kestenbaum v. Falstaff Brewing Corp., 514 F.2d 690 (5th Cir. 1975) (valuation and evidence guidance in bankruptcy context)
  • Klapmeier v. Telecheck Intern., Inc., 482 F.2d 247 (8th Cir. 1973) (valuation testimony by non-experts and relevance standards)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: In Re Darosa
Court Name: United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Massachusetts
Date Published: Nov 17, 2010
Citations: 442 B.R. 173; 2010 Bankr. LEXIS 4140; 2010 WL 4777548; 10-44471
Docket Number: 10-44471
Court Abbreviation: Bankr. D. Mass.
Log In