442 B.R. 173
Bankr. D. Mass.2010Background
- Debtor Jorge H. Darosa filed for bankruptcy in the District of Massachusetts; U.S. Bank National Association seeks relief from the automatic stay to foreclose its mortgage on property in Lowell, MA.
- Bank requested relief under 11 U.S.C. §362(d)(1) (for cause, including lack of adequate protection) or §362(d)(2) (lack of equity and not necessary to reorganization).
- Bank bore the burden to prove lack of equity under §362(g); local rule requires stating fair market value and liquidation value with supporting appraisals.
- Bank initially valued the Lowell property by the tax assessor’s valuation, leading the court to deny relief without prejudice for lack of acceptable valuation basis.
- At a reconsideration hearing, the bank presented a drive-by property evaluation valuing the property at $205,000; the bank owed over $360,000.
- The court granted relief from stay based on the drive-by valuation, while clarifying that tax assessor valuations are not an acceptable, standalone basis for determining value under §362(d).
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| May tax assessor value establish lack of equity? | Bank argues tax assessment can reflect value for lack of equity. | Darosa contends tax assessments are not reliable current value for relief from stay. | Tax assessor valuations are not acceptable alone to prove lack of equity. |
| Is a drive-by valuation reliable enough to establish lack of equity? | Bank offers drive-by valuation showing no equity. | Debtor and court require persuasive, case-specific reliability beyond Internet or public data. | Drive-by appraisal can establish lack of equity; court accepts $205,000 value as credible for relief from stay. |
| Can a debtor's scheduled value support a lack of equity finding? | Scheduled value admitted as debtor’s valuation in proceedings. | Court should require reliable current valuation rather than solely relying on schedules. | The scheduled value may support lack of equity if reliable, but in this case the court relies on the drive-by valuation for relief. |
Key Cases Cited
- Shane v. Shane, 891 F.2d 976 (1st Cir. 1989) (owner competent to testify about value of own property)
- Robinson v. Watts Detective Agency, Inc., 685 F.2d 729 (1st Cir. 1982) (testimony about value by owner admissible)
- In re Healthco Intern., Inc., 257 B.R. 379 (Bankr. D. Mass. 2001) (tax assessments not sole basis for credibility in value disputes)
- U.S. v. 10,031.98 Acres of Land, More or Less, Situate in Las Animas County, Colo., 850 F.2d 634 (10th Cir. 1988) (valorization and credibility of land valuations considerations)
- Carlucci, 2010 WL 3895500 (Bankr. D. N.H. 2010) (tax assessments may be used as a factor in valuation but not sole basis)
- Justice v. Pennzoil Co., 598 F.2d 1339 (4th Cir. 1979) (valuation considerations in property disputes)
- Kestenbaum v. Falstaff Brewing Corp., 514 F.2d 690 (5th Cir. 1975) (valuation and evidence guidance in bankruptcy context)
- Klapmeier v. Telecheck Intern., Inc., 482 F.2d 247 (8th Cir. 1973) (valuation testimony by non-experts and relevance standards)