2016 Ohio 2683
Ohio Ct. App.2016Background
- Decedent Richard L. Burton Sr. died intestate on December 22, 2014. His children (including appellant Gerald Burton) contested estate administration.
- Probate court appointed Angela Fugate (aka Burton), Richard Sr.’s wife (married April 12, 1987), as administrator on February 19, 2015.
- Gerald and other children moved to remove Angela as administrator alleging neglect, fraud, and criminal acts; the probate court held a hearing and denied removal for lack of credible evidence.
- Gerald appealed, arguing (1) the probate court erred by refusing to remove Angela as fiduciary; (2) Richard’s 1987 marriage to Angela was invalid; and (3) Richard had a prior valid common-law marriage with his mother, Marsha.
- The probate court found witnesses not credible, concluded the 1987 marriage to Angela stood (at worst voidable and not dissolved), and held the common-law marriage issue barred by prior domestic-relations adjudication (res judicata) and/or rendered void by polygamy concerns.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether administrator Angela should be removed for misconduct or incompetence | Gerald: Angela neglected duties and engaged in fraudulent/criminal acts warranting removal under R.C. 2109.24 / 2113.18 | Probate court: testimony and evidence lacked credibility; no statutory basis shown for removal | Court affirmed: removal lies within probate court discretion; credibility findings support denial |
| Whether the 1987 marriage between Richard and Angela was invalid | Gerald: officiant (Rev. Robinson) not shown to be licensed, so marriage invalid | Angela: prior Ohio law allowed ministers to register with probate judges; at worst marriage would be voidable and was never dissolved | Court affirmed: marriage valid at death (voidable only, no annulment), so spouse status stands |
| Whether Richard had a valid common-law marriage with Marsha | Gerald: claims prior/common-law union giving Marsha spousal rights | Angela / court: issue previously litigated and rejected in domestic relations court; later alleged common-law union would be polygamous and void given Richard’s subsequent marriage | Court affirmed: res judicata bars relitigation and any later common-law claim is void/polygamous |
Key Cases Cited
- Seasons Coal Co. v. City of Cleveland, 10 Ohio St.3d 77 (Ohio 1984) (credibility determinations are for the trier of fact)
- State v. DePew, 38 Ohio St.3d 275 (Ohio 1988) (elements of common-law marriage and related principles)
- Nestor v. Nestor, 15 Ohio St.3d 143 (Ohio 1984) (common-law marriage principles)
- Mazzolini v. Mazzolini, 168 Ohio St. 357 (Ohio 1958) (polygamous marriages are void)
- Darling v. Darling, 44 Ohio App.2d 5 (Ohio Ct. App. 1975) (distinguishing void vs. voidable marriages)
- In re Estate of Kendall, 171 Ohio App.3d 109 (Ohio Ct. App. 2007) (trial court as best judge of witness credibility)