458 B.R. 444
Bankr. N.D. Ill.2011Background
- Timothy K. Liou is a highly active consumer bankruptcy attorney in the district, facing sanctions for filing allegedly false fee applications.
- Seven bankruptcy judges issued orders finding Liou filed false applications in 317 Chapter 13 cases by claiming he had a Court-Approved Retention Agreement (MRA) with a flat $3,500 fee, when he had modified it with an addendum to charge more.
- The court consolidated Rule 9011(b) proceedings, conducted hearings, and concluded Liou violated Rule 9011(b) by misrepresenting the existence of the MRA in fee applications.
- Since 2002, the Northern District of Illinois adopted a flat-fee system with MRAs; over time the court raised flat fees and required MRAs to be in writing and attached to Rule 2016(b) statements.
- The MRA allowed two compensation options, with a presumptively reasonable flat fee and the possibility of extraordinary additional fees only with an itemized application; Liou’s addendum purportedly added such extra charges.
- Liou’s use of the addendum often accompanied MRAs, but the court found the addendum modified the MRA in a way that altered the compensation arrangement, contradicting the flat-fee model.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether Liou’s fee applications falsely stated he entered the MRA. | Liou (Liou) allegedly entered into the MRA with debtors in each case. | Liou contends the MRA and addendum were separate or that the statements literally reflected the MRA. | Liou violated Rule 9011(b)(3); misrepresentations were false. |
| Whether the addendum modified the MRA and rendered the representations misleading. | The addendum did not alter the MRA and was separate. | The addendum was part of a single agreement and changed fees beyond the flat rate. | The addendum modified the MRA; representations were misleading. |
| Whether Liou acted with culpable carelessness under Rule 9011(b)(3). | Liou knowingly misrepresented facts or acted with gross negligence. | Liou relied on counsel and believed his representations were reasonable. | Liou’s conduct was culpably careless; sanctions justified. |
| What sanction is appropriate for Liou’s Rule 9011(b)(3) violations. | Severe sanction is warranted given pattern and harm to the process. | Liou argues for lighter sanctions based on corrective actions and lack of intent. | Impose $10,000 fine, require legal ethics course, issue public censure, and refer for disciplinary action. |
Key Cases Cited
- In re Nelson, 424 B.R. 361 (Bankr.N.D.Ill.2009) (attorney fee issues and Rule 2016 disclosures control integrity of process)
- In re Kindhart, 160 F.3d 1176 (7th Cir.1998) (attorney fees in Chapter 13 and flat-fee considerations)
- In re Eliapo, 468 F.3d 592 (9th Cir.2006) (lodestar and flat-fee considerations in bankruptcy context)
- In re Geraci, 138 F.3d 314 (7th Cir.1998) (approval of presumptively reasonable flat fees in Chapter 7 and 13)
- In re Mortakis, 405 B.R. 293 (Bankr.N.D.Ill.2009) (modifications to MRAs and related fee considerations)
- Vollmer v. Selden, 350 F.3d 656 (7th Cir.2003) (sanctions standards and deterrence in Rule 11/9011 contexts)
- In re Kowalski, 402 B.R. 843 (Bankr.N.D.Ill.2009) (disciplinary implications in bankruptcy attorney practices)