2023 Ohio 166
Ohio Ct. App.2023Background
- A.W., born May 2020, was removed in August 2020 after mother had a postpartum/mental-health crisis; LCCS obtained temporary custody and A.W. has been in agency care since September 2020.
- Mother moved repeatedly (Ohio, Arizona, back to Ohio), participated intermittently in mental-health counseling and parenting services, and at times lived in shelters or transient housing.
- Caseworkers and CASA reported ongoing concerns: inconsistent mental-health treatment, unstable housing, parenting deficiencies (choking hazards, poor redirection, giving coffee), and limited verified supports.
- A.W. received therapy for developmental needs and bonded with his foster caregivers, who (and whose relatives) wanted to adopt; CASA recommended permanent custody to LCCS.
- Juvenile court found statutory grounds under R.C. 2151.414(E)(1) and (4) (and B(1)(d) custodial-history ground), concluded permanent custody to LCCS served A.W.’s best interest, and granted the agency permanent custody.
- Mother appealed, arguing the agency failed to prove by clear and convincing evidence that A.W. could not be placed with her within a reasonable time.
Issues
| Issue | Appellant's Argument | LCCS's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether clear and convincing evidence showed A.W. could not be placed with mother within a reasonable time (R.C. 2151.414(B)(1)(a)) | Mother: she engaged in services, completed parenting class in Arizona, visited regularly (including video), and had recent stable housing — agency failed to prove she continuously and repeatedly failed to remedy removal causes | LCCS: child had been in agency custody >12 of 22 months; mother remained inconsistent with mental-health treatment, housing, and parenting; child’s need for permanence and progress in foster care favor permanent custody | Affirmed: court found clear and convincing evidence for R.C. 2151.414(E)(1) and (4) and B(1)(d); permanent custody to LCCS in child’s best interest |
Key Cases Cited
- Seasons Coal Co. v. Cleveland, 10 Ohio St.3d 77 (1984) (trial judge best positioned to assess witness credibility)
- Karches v. Cincinnati, 38 Ohio St.3d 12 (1988) (appellate courts must presume correctness of trial-court findings)
- C.E. Morris Co. v. Foley Constr. Co., 54 Ohio St.2d 279 (1978) (judgment supported by competent, credible evidence is not against the manifest weight)
- Cross v. Ledford, 161 Ohio St. 469 (1954) (clear-and-convincing standard defined)
- State v. Schiebel, 55 Ohio St.3d 71 (1990) (reviewing clear-and-convincing proof by examining record sufficiency)