midpage
2011 Ohio 5083
Ohio
2011

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Huff injured June 2004 by a falling limb of a sugar maple near Kings Grave Road in Hartford Township; tree located on Braho property, about 30 feet from road center and 20 feet from Ohio Edison power lines.
  • Tree was outside Ohio Edison’s easement; it did not threaten the lines.
  • Ohio Edison hired Asplundh Tree Expert Company to inspect and maintain vegetation along the lines but deferred to Asplundh’s decisions; Asplundh had last been in the area in May 2001.
  • Plaintiffs sued Ohio Edison and Asplundh (and others) for failure to inspect, maintain, remove the tree, or warn public of danger.
  • Trial court granted summary judgment, finding no notice or duty by either party and that Huff was not an intended third-party beneficiary of the contract.
  • Court of appeals reversed, concluding there was a genuine issue whether Huff was an intended third-party beneficiary under the contract; majority held the contract did not create such a duty.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether Huff is an intended third-party beneficiary of the Ohio Edison–Asplundh contract Huff argues the contract’s safeguard clause creates a duty to protect the public Edison/Asplundh argue no intent to benefit Huff; no contract language shows intended beneficiary Not an intended beneficiary; contract language and purpose do not show intent to benefit Huff

Key Cases Cited

  • Hill v. Sonitrol of Southwestern Ohio, Inc., 36 Ohio St.3d 36 (1988) (adopts Restatement §302 test for intended beneficiaries)
  • Norfolk & West. Co. v. United States, 641 F.2d 1201 (C.A.6. 1980) (intent-to-benefit test for third-party beneficiaries)
  • Anderson v. Olmsted Util. Equip., Inc., 60 Ohio St.3d 124 (1991) (extrinsic evidence may establish third-party rights; city example)
  • Shifrin v. Forest City Ents., Inc., 64 Ohio St.3d 635 (1992) (language controls, extrinsic evidence used to interpret intent")
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Huff v. FirstEnergy Corp.
Court Name: Ohio Supreme Court
Date Published: Oct 5, 2011
Citations: 2011 Ohio 5083; 130 Ohio St. 3d 196; 957 N.E.2d 3; 2010-0857
Docket Number: 2010-0857
Court Abbreviation: Ohio
Log In