midpage
56 F. Supp. 3d 709
E.D. Pa.
2014

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • In 1989 Melvin Howard was convicted of first-degree murder; his death sentence was vacated in 2011 and he was resentenced to life without parole. The murder conviction rested largely on one eyewitness, Hezekiah Sermons.
  • Howard filed a federal habeas petition raising nine claims; Magistrate Judge Sitarski recommended denial and the District Court adopted that R&R, overruling Howard’s objections to four claims (A, B, C, E).
  • Claim A: ineffective assistance of trial counsel (IAC) for failing to investigate/present mental‑health and background evidence that Howard asserts would support lesser homicide defenses (provocation/heat of passion; diminished capacity; imperfect self‑defense).
  • Claim B: Batson challenge — Howard alleged the prosecutor used peremptory strikes discriminatorily and that trial/appellate counsel were ineffective for failing to press Batson objections.
  • Claim C: prosecutorial misconduct in closing argument (various comments about witness military service, failure to call a witness, faulting defendant for not producing evidence, appeal to sympathy/public safety) and related IAC for not objecting.
  • Claim E: IAC for failing to timely request a jury instruction that no adverse inference be drawn from Howard’s decision not to testify (Carter instruction); Pennsylvania Supreme Court found performance deficient but no prejudice.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
IAC for failing to investigate/present mental‑health/background evidence (Claim A) Howard: evidence of mental retardation, PTSD, personality disorder would support manslaughter/diminished‑capacity defenses and undermine guilt Commonwealth: presenting mental‑health evidence would undercut trial strategy of asserting actual innocence and would not satisfy objective elements of the lesser defenses Denied — counsel reasonably pursued an actual‑innocence strategy; mental‑health evidence would not likely produce prejudice or satisfy elements of lesser offenses
Batson claim and IAC for failing to litigate it (Claim B) Howard: statistical data and evidence of a discriminatory culture in DA’s office show race‑based strikes; counsel ineffective for not preserving/raising Batson Commonwealth: panel statistics and proffered cultural materials insufficient; prosecutor gave race‑neutral reason (age/gender) for strike; no prima facie showing Denied — no prima facie showing; prosecutor offered race‑neutral reasons; counsel not ineffective since Batson claim lacked merit
Prosecutorial misconduct in closing and IAC for failing to object (Claim C) Howard: numerous improper statements (vouching via military references, comments on failure to call witnesses, urging sympathy/public‑safety rationale) deprived him of due process Commonwealth: statements were permissible responses to defense, fair inferences, and curative instructions were given; not cumulatively prejudicial Denied — comments, considered individually and cumulatively, did not so infect the trial to deprive Howard of due process; curative instructions and context cured any potential prejudice
Failure to timely request Carter (no‑adverse‑inference) instruction; IAC (Claim E) Howard: counsel’s late request deprived jury of instruction that silence cannot be used as evidence of guilt and was therefore prejudicial Commonwealth: trial judge and PA Supreme Court found counsel’s omission unreasonable but the error was not prejudicial under federal Brecht/Strickland analysis given voir‑dire/instruction history and strong evidence Denied — state court’s application of Strickland/Brecht was reasonable: performance deficient but petitioner failed to show substantial and injurious effect on verdict

Key Cases Cited

  • Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (ineffective assistance standard: performance and prejudice prongs)
  • Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (peremptory strikes may not be race‑based; three‑step Batson framework)
  • Carter v. Kentucky, 450 U.S. 288 (trial court must give no‑adverse‑inference instruction upon defendant’s request)
  • Brecht v. Abrahamson, 507 U.S. 619 (habeas harmless‑error standard: substantial and injurious effect)
  • Harrington v. Richter, 562 U.S. 86 (deference to state court Strickland determinations under AEDPA)
  • Williams v. Taylor, 529 U.S. 362 (AEDPA standards and relation to Strickland)
  • Griffin v. California, 380 U.S. 609 (prosecutorial comment on defendant’s silence can be unconstitutional)
  • Darden v. Wainwright, 477 U.S. 168 (prosecutorial misconduct must render trial unfair to violate due process)
  • Commonwealth v. Howard, 645 A.2d 1300 (Pa. 1994) (Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision addressing Carter/instruction and counsel performance)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Howard v. Horn
Court Name: District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania
Date Published: Nov 4, 2014
Citations: 56 F. Supp. 3d 709; 2014 WL 5660822; 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 156528; Civil Action No. 99-4880
Docket Number: Civil Action No. 99-4880
Court Abbreviation: E.D. Pa.
Log In