midpage
909 N.W.2d 59
Neb.
2018

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Paul H. Hemsley underwent coronary artery bypass surgery performed by Dr. Thomas Langdon; a chest tube was placed during the procedure.
  • Postoperatively Hemsley developed fever and fecal material was noted from his chest incision; Dr. John Batter performed a second operation and discovered and repaired a transverse colon injury.
  • Hemsley later developed sepsis/peritonitis and died; the Estate sued the surgeons and their practice for medical malpractice under the Nebraska Hospital-Medical Liability Act.
  • Before trial the Estate moved in limine and to exclude the defendants’ expert testimony, arguing the experts failed to disclose methodologies and reasoning as required by Daubert/Schafersman.
  • The district court reserved ruling but ultimately overruled the Estate’s Daubert/Schafersman objections, admitting defense experts who testified the surgeons met the standard of care; a jury returned verdict for defendants.
  • The Estate’s posttrial motions (new trial, JNOV, strike opinions) were denied; the Estate appealed alleging the court abdicated its gatekeeping duty.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether the court abdicated Daubert/Schafersman gatekeeping for expert testimony on standard of care Estate: Experts failed to disclose methodology/reasoning; therefore testimony should have been excluded Doctors: Expert testimony was ordinary, experience-based standard-of-care opinion, not novel science requiring full Daubert analysis Court: No abdication—judge conducted a flexible Daubert inquiry, found testimony based on experts’ personal knowledge and qualifications and admissible
Whether standard-of-care testimony in malpractice cases always requires Daubert-factor analysis Estate: Standard-of-care opinions must disclose methodology and satisfy Daubert factors Doctors: Standard-of-care testimony often derives from experts’ experience and customary practice; Daubert factors may be inapplicable or less relevant Court: Daubert/Schafersman applies but inquiry is flexible; Daubert factors may or may not be pertinent depending on testimony and objections
Whether the defense experts’ testimony satisfied reliability requirements Estate: Education alone insufficient; experts needed to show methods and application to facts Doctors: Experts’ training, experience, CVs, and testimony about their practices provided reliable basis Court: Admissible—experts’ qualifications and empirical, experience-based testimony were sufficient and Estate did not adequately challenge reliability
Whether posttrial relief was required given admission of experts Estate: Erroneous admission prejudiced outcome, warranting new trial or JNOV Doctors: No abuse of discretion in evidentiary rulings; verdict stands Court: No abuse of discretion; posttrial motions properly overruled; judgment affirmed

Key Cases Cited

  • Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (trial-court gatekeeping factors for scientific expert admissibility)
  • Schafersman v. Agland Coop, 262 Neb. 215 (Nebraska adoption of Daubert framework)
  • Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael, 526 U.S. 137 (Daubert gatekeeping applies to non-scientific experts; inquiry is flexible)
  • Zimmerman v. Powell, 268 Neb. 422 (trial court must make record findings when performing gatekeeping)
  • Rankin v. Stetson, 275 Neb. 775 (application of Daubert to standard-of-care testimony in malpractice context)
  • Murray v. UNMC Physicians, 282 Neb. 260 (statutory standard of care cannot be altered by courts)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Hemsley v. Langdon
Court Name: Nebraska Supreme Court
Date Published: Mar 30, 2018
Citations: 909 N.W.2d 59; 299 Neb. 464; S-16-1123
Docket Number: S-16-1123
Court Abbreviation: Neb.
Log In