midpage
498 F. Supp. 3d 400
W.D.N.Y.
2020

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Plaintiff Jacob Grice sued defendant Phil McMurdy (and 25 John Doe defendants) alleging breach of a 2012 consignment contract, fraud, fraudulent transfers, unjust enrichment, and intentional infliction of emotional distress for unpaid sports memorabilia and related breaches.
  • Grice delivered two pallets of sports memorabilia on June 10–11, 2012; he alleges McMurdy failed to pay and failed to maintain required insurance.
  • Complaint filed June 7, 2018; McMurdy was served August 21, 2018; defendant did not answer and the Clerk entered default on April 18, 2019.
  • Grice moved for default judgment under Fed. R. Civ. P. 55(b)(1), seeking $983,758 based on an appraiser’s valuation of the memorabilia.
  • The Court found the claimed damages were not a “sum certain” capable of clerical entry and denied the Rule 55(b)(1) request without prejudice, instructing Grice to move under Rule 55(b)(2) and permitting refiling within 30 days; Grice must serve the Decision and Order and file proof of service.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether the Clerk may enter default judgment under Rule 55(b)(1) for the requested damages Grice contends the appraiser’s valuation ($983,758) fixes the amount due, allowing clerk entry No responsive opposition (default) Denied: appraisal is an estimate of converted property value, not a “sum certain” for clerical entry; court must determine damages under Rule 55(b)(2)
Whether default alone entitles Grice to a default judgment without addressing discretionary factors Implicit: default and Clerk’s prior entry justify judgment No responsive argument (default) Denied: plaintiff must still show entitlement; court considers willfulness of default, meritorious defenses, and prejudice before awarding default judgment
Whether inclusion of John Doe defendants destroys diversity jurisdiction Grice alleges complete diversity (he is Oregon, McMurdy New York) and amount > $75,000 N/A Inclusion of unnamed Doe defendants does not automatically defeat diversity; jurisdiction appears proper for now
Next procedural step and timing Grice asks for immediate judgment N/A Court denied without prejudice and permitted a motion for default judgment under Rule 55(b)(2) within 30 days; must serve Decision & Order and file proof of service

Key Cases Cited

  • Thorpe v. Thorpe, 364 F.2d 692 (D.C. Cir. 1966) (discussing when an amount is a “sum certain” for clerk entry)
  • Combs v. Coal & Mineral Mgmt. Servs., Inc., 105 F.R.D. 472 (D.D.C. 1985) (clerk entry appropriate when liability amount is mathematically certain)
  • United States v. Raleigh Restaurant, 398 F. Supp. 496 (E.D.N.Y. 1975) (example of a sum certain: delinquent tax assessment)
  • Richmond v. Smith, 127 F.R.D. 178 (D. Nev. 1989) (conversion/value of personal property is not a sum certain)
  • Sette-Hughes v. Sprauve, [citation="663 F. App'x 10"] (2d Cir. 2016) (appraisal evidence may be used by court to determine damages after default)
  • Greyhound Exhibitgroup, Inc. v. E.L.U.L. Realty Corp., 973 F.2d 155 (2d Cir. 1992) (default concedes liability allegations but not damages)
  • Credit Lyonnais Sec. (USA), Inc. v. Alcantara, 183 F.3d 151 (2d Cir. 1999) (district court must ascertain damages with reasonable certainty despite default)
  • Pecarsky v. Galaxiworld.com, Ltd., 249 F.3d 167 (2d Cir. 2001) (factors for vacating default/default judgment: willfulness, meritorious defense, prejudice)
  • Enron Oil Corp. v. Diakuhara, 10 F.3d 90 (2d Cir. 1993) (district courts have discretion over default judgment motions)
  • Doe v. Ciolli, 611 F. Supp. 2d 216 (D. Conn. 2009) (inclusion of John Doe defendants does not automatically defeat diversity jurisdiction)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Grice v. McMurdy
Court Name: District Court, W.D. New York
Date Published: Jan 8, 2020
Citations: 498 F. Supp. 3d 400; 2020 WL 90770; 6:18-cv-06414
Docket Number: 6:18-cv-06414
Court Abbreviation: W.D.N.Y.
Log In