498 F. Supp. 3d 400
W.D.N.Y.2020Background
- Plaintiff Jacob Grice sued defendant Phil McMurdy (and 25 John Doe defendants) alleging breach of a 2012 consignment contract, fraud, fraudulent transfers, unjust enrichment, and intentional infliction of emotional distress for unpaid sports memorabilia and related breaches.
- Grice delivered two pallets of sports memorabilia on June 10–11, 2012; he alleges McMurdy failed to pay and failed to maintain required insurance.
- Complaint filed June 7, 2018; McMurdy was served August 21, 2018; defendant did not answer and the Clerk entered default on April 18, 2019.
- Grice moved for default judgment under Fed. R. Civ. P. 55(b)(1), seeking $983,758 based on an appraiser’s valuation of the memorabilia.
- The Court found the claimed damages were not a “sum certain” capable of clerical entry and denied the Rule 55(b)(1) request without prejudice, instructing Grice to move under Rule 55(b)(2) and permitting refiling within 30 days; Grice must serve the Decision and Order and file proof of service.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the Clerk may enter default judgment under Rule 55(b)(1) for the requested damages | Grice contends the appraiser’s valuation ($983,758) fixes the amount due, allowing clerk entry | No responsive opposition (default) | Denied: appraisal is an estimate of converted property value, not a “sum certain” for clerical entry; court must determine damages under Rule 55(b)(2) |
| Whether default alone entitles Grice to a default judgment without addressing discretionary factors | Implicit: default and Clerk’s prior entry justify judgment | No responsive argument (default) | Denied: plaintiff must still show entitlement; court considers willfulness of default, meritorious defenses, and prejudice before awarding default judgment |
| Whether inclusion of John Doe defendants destroys diversity jurisdiction | Grice alleges complete diversity (he is Oregon, McMurdy New York) and amount > $75,000 | N/A | Inclusion of unnamed Doe defendants does not automatically defeat diversity; jurisdiction appears proper for now |
| Next procedural step and timing | Grice asks for immediate judgment | N/A | Court denied without prejudice and permitted a motion for default judgment under Rule 55(b)(2) within 30 days; must serve Decision & Order and file proof of service |
Key Cases Cited
- Thorpe v. Thorpe, 364 F.2d 692 (D.C. Cir. 1966) (discussing when an amount is a “sum certain” for clerk entry)
- Combs v. Coal & Mineral Mgmt. Servs., Inc., 105 F.R.D. 472 (D.D.C. 1985) (clerk entry appropriate when liability amount is mathematically certain)
- United States v. Raleigh Restaurant, 398 F. Supp. 496 (E.D.N.Y. 1975) (example of a sum certain: delinquent tax assessment)
- Richmond v. Smith, 127 F.R.D. 178 (D. Nev. 1989) (conversion/value of personal property is not a sum certain)
- Sette-Hughes v. Sprauve, [citation="663 F. App'x 10"] (2d Cir. 2016) (appraisal evidence may be used by court to determine damages after default)
- Greyhound Exhibitgroup, Inc. v. E.L.U.L. Realty Corp., 973 F.2d 155 (2d Cir. 1992) (default concedes liability allegations but not damages)
- Credit Lyonnais Sec. (USA), Inc. v. Alcantara, 183 F.3d 151 (2d Cir. 1999) (district court must ascertain damages with reasonable certainty despite default)
- Pecarsky v. Galaxiworld.com, Ltd., 249 F.3d 167 (2d Cir. 2001) (factors for vacating default/default judgment: willfulness, meritorious defense, prejudice)
- Enron Oil Corp. v. Diakuhara, 10 F.3d 90 (2d Cir. 1993) (district courts have discretion over default judgment motions)
- Doe v. Ciolli, 611 F. Supp. 2d 216 (D. Conn. 2009) (inclusion of John Doe defendants does not automatically defeat diversity jurisdiction)