Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.2018Background
- Plaintiff Trevis L. Funches, a prison inmate, alleges (1) Fourteenth Amendment due process violations arising from lack of access to requested documents at a disciplinary hearing and confinement in SHU with allegedly discolored water, and (2) First Amendment retaliation by prison officials (Russo, Morris, McKoy) including a retaliatory cell search/confiscation and suspension of correspondence privileges.
- Defendants moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), arguing insufficient pleading of a protected liberty interest, adequate procedural safeguards at the disciplinary hearing, absence of retaliatory adverse action, and entitlement to qualified immunity.
- Magistrate Judge Stewart recommended denial of the motion in full, finding the amended complaint plausibly alleged (a) due process violations against Greene and Polizzi, and (b) First Amendment retaliation claims against Russo, Morris, and McKoy; and that qualified immunity was not appropriate for the defendants.
- Several defendants filed specific objections; the district court reviewed objections de novo where they raised new arguments and for clear error otherwise.
- The district court: adopted the Report-Recommendation in part, denied the motion in part, allowed due process claims against Greene and Polizzi and retaliation claims against Russo and Morris to proceed, but dismissed the retaliation claim against McKoy and found McKoy entitled to qualified immunity.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Due process—Greene: failure to provide requested documents at disciplinary hearing | Greene withheld Unusual Incident Report, memos, and medical records needed for defense | Documents were read into evidence at hearing; Wolff permits withholding irrelevant/unsafe materials; complaint shows no atypical/ significant hardship | Survives: at pleading stage, plausible that documents were withheld without permissible reason; reading into evidence does not cure nondisclosure |
| Due process—Polizzi: adjudicator’s role in upholding disciplinary finding | Polizzi failed to remedy Greene’s nondisclosure and decision may lack sufficient supporting evidence | Court should apply "some evidence" standard; magistrate improperly weighed evidence | Survives: claim based on failure to permit presentation of requested documentary evidence stands; but court rejected magistrate’s separate rationale that evidence was insufficient (wrong inquiry at pleading stage) |
| First Amendment—Russo: cell search and confiscation of hot pot as adverse action | Search ordered after Russo questioned plaintiff about grievances; confiscation of non‑contraband hot pot was retaliatory | Routine cell searches and seizure of property are expected; Jones suggests such searches are not actionable absent Eighth Amendment level harm | Survives: allegation that search/confiscation was motivated by retaliation and involved non‑contraband property plausibly states a claim |
| First Amendment—Morris: suspension of correspondence privileges with plaintiff’s son | Morris targeted plaintiff after complaints and instigated suspension under DOCCS directive; action motivated by retaliation | Suspension followed Directive 4422 for verification problems and would have occurred regardless of grievances | Survives: complaint plausibly alleges retaliatory motive (March interaction) and facts permit inference requiring discovery |
| First Amendment—McKoy & supervisory liability; qualified immunity | McKoy failed to remedy suspension after being informed, establishing personal involvement | McKoy merely complied with DOCCS directive and had no duty to approve correspondence; qualified immunity applies | Dismissed: supervisory liability under Colon (failure to remedy) is pleaded, but uncertainty after Iqbal about Colon’s continued vitality creates law ambiguity; court grants McKoy qualified immunity and dismisses him |
Key Cases Cited
- Wolff v. McDonnell, 418 U.S. 539 (1974) (prison disciplinary due process protections and limits on inmate rights to call witnesses/documents)
- Freeman v. Rideout, 808 F.2d 949 (2d Cir. 1986) (discussion of Wolff’s scope regarding prison discretion in disciplinary proceedings)
- Superintendent, Mass. Corr. Inst., Walpole v. Hill, 472 U.S. 445 (1985) ("some evidence" standard for review of prison disciplinary findings)
- Ayers v. Ryan, 152 F.3d 77 (2d Cir. 1998) (employee assistant’s failure to assist inmate can violate due process)
- Franco v. Kelly, 854 F.2d 584 (2d Cir. 1988) (applying deferential "some evidence" review to prison disciplinary findings)
- Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (2009) (heightened pleading standards and impact on supervisory‑liability doctrines)
- Reichle v. Howards, 566 U.S. 658 (2012) (qualified immunity requires clearly established law such that every reasonable official would know conduct was unlawful)
- Colon v. Coughlin, 58 F.3d 865 (2d Cir. 1995) (five categories for establishing supervisory liability)