Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.2018Background
- Plaintiff, a DOCCS inmate, was issued an inmate misbehavior report (June 30, 2017) and received disciplinary sanctions including 120 days in SHU on three charges; one charge (assault on an inmate) was dismissed.
- Plaintiff alleges his employee assistant (Greene) failed to provide requested documents pre-hearing and the hearing officer (Polizzi) failed to provide or consider necessary documentary/witness evidence, and relied on stale incidents.
- Plaintiff alleges Russo investigated a grievance and, after questioning Plaintiff about filings, directed a cell search and confiscation of Plaintiff’s hot pot as retaliation.
- Plaintiff alleges Morris revoked or caused return of correspondence from incarcerated relatives after criticizing Plaintiff’s staff complaints; McKoy failed to remedy the correspondence denial (later reinstated).
- Defendants moved to dismiss the amended complaint in full; the magistrate judge recommends denial of the motion as to the remaining Fourteenth Amendment due process claims (against Greene, Polizzi) and First Amendment retaliation claims (against Russo, Morris, McKoy).
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Existence of protected liberty interest from 120-day SHU term and conditions | 120 days plus allegedly poor SHU conditions (stained water) create an atypical and significant hardship | 120 days alone (101–305 days) insufficient without pleading significant aggravating conditions | Denied dismissal: 120 days places plaintiff in intermediate-duration zone; alleged conditions permit discovery on atypicality |
| Adequacy of due process in disciplinary hearing (employee assistant & access to documents, witness denial, insufficient evidence) | Greene failed to provide requested documents; Polizzi failed to remedy, denied witness, relied on insufficient evidence | Defendants: not entitled to every document; evidence supported findings | Denied dismissal: factual disputes about withheld materials, witness denial, and evidentiary sufficiency must be resolved later |
| Retaliation claim for cell search & property confiscation (Russo) | Investigation/questioning of grievances led to cell search and confiscation of hot pot as retaliation for protected grievance activity | Search/property action was lawful and not retaliatory | Denied dismissal: confiscation of personal property during a search can be adverse action sufficient to state a retaliation claim |
| Retaliation claim for revocation/return of correspondence (Morris) and failure to remedy (McKoy) | Morris told plaintiff to stop filing complaints then correspondence was cut off; McKoy failed to timely restore approved correspondence | Defendants: correspondence restriction lawful under DOCCS directive; approvals lacked or were justified; privilege later reinstated | Denied dismissal: plaintiff alleges preexisting approvals and temporal link to complaints; reinstatement and policy defenses raise factual issues for discovery |
Key Cases Cited
- Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (plausibility standard for complaints)
- Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (pleading must state a plausible claim)
- Wolff v. McDonnell, 418 U.S. 539 (due process rights in prison disciplinary proceedings)
- Kalwasinski v. Morse, 201 F.3d 103 (2d Cir. standards for prison disciplinary hearings)
- Reichle v. Howards, 566 U.S. 658 (qualified immunity requires clearly established law)
- Anderson v. Creighton, 483 U.S. 635 (qualified immunity scope)
- Dawes v. Walker, 239 F.3d 489 (retaliation claims in prison context warrant skepticism)
- Holland v. Goord, 758 F.3d 215 (elements of a First Amendment retaliation claim)
- Scott v. Coughlin, 344 F.3d 282 (prisoner complaints are protected activity for retaliation claims)
- Espinoza ex rel. JPMorgan Chase & Co. v. Dimon, 797 F.3d 229 (standard for courts on Rule 12(b)(6) review)