635 B.R. 568
Bankr. D. Mont.2022Background
- In 2015 nineteen Shoot the Moon entities merged into Shoot the Moon, LLC and promptly filed chapter 11; Jeremiah Foster was later appointed chapter 11 trustee and then liquidating trustee.
- In 2016 the Trustee sought to sell substantially all estate assets; several secured creditors (including First Interstate Bank and Prairie Mountain Bank/American Bank Center) agreed conditionally via a stipulation that included a broad mutual release of "any and all" known and unknown claims arising before approval.
- The bankruptcy court approved the sale and incorporated the stipulation (and its broad release) into a final order; the Trustee did not appeal that order.
- Nearly five years later the Trustee filed an adversary complaint alleging the lenders knew of and participated in a multi-year check‑kiting scheme and that the Trustee’s consent to the release was obtained by fraud (fraudulent concealment / nondisclosure).
- Defendants moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), arguing the court‑approved release bars the claims and that the complaint fails to plead facts invalidating the release.
- The bankruptcy court held the complaint alleged only passive nondisclosure, not the affirmative acts Montana law requires to show fraudulent concealment, and therefore the release barred the asserted claims; dismissal was granted with leave to amend.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the court‑approved release bars Trustee’s claims | Trustee says release was procured by fraud and is void, so claims survive | Release is broad and final; it bars Trustee’s claims | Release bars the claims as pled; dismissal appropriate |
| Whether defendants’ alleged nondisclosure equals actionable fraud/concealment | Trustee: lenders concealed involvement in check‑kiting when negotiating release | Defendants: mere failure to volunteer information is not fraud; no affirmative concealment alleged | Mere nondisclosure insufficient under Montana law; complaint fails to plead affirmative concealment |
| Whether a special duty to disclose exists in settlement negotiations ("peculiar knowledge") | Trustee: lenders had "peculiar knowledge" creating duty to volunteer facts | Defendants: no authority imposes such duty on adversaries; would undermine settlements | Court rejects a general duty to volunteer unrequested information in this context |
| Procedural remedy: dismissal standard and amendment | Trustee seeks to proceed or amend | Defendants seek dismissal with prejudice | Dismissal under Rule 12(b)(6) granted but leave to amend allowed (must plead affirmative acts) |
Key Cases Cited
- Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (pleading must state a plausible claim)
- Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (plausibility standard for complaints)
- Wellness Int’l Network, Ltd. v. Sharif, 575 U.S. 665 (bankruptcy litigant may consent to entry of final judgment by the bankruptcy court)
- Facebook, Inc. v. Pac. Nw. Software, Inc., 640 F.3d 1034 (enforce clear releases between adversaries; parties in equal bargaining positions expected to use discovery)
- Wolfe v. Flathead Elec. Coop., Inc., 393 Mont. 312 (Montana requires affirmative acts to prove fraudulent concealment)
- Skilstaf, Inc. v. CVS Caremark Corp., 669 F.3d 1005 (claims barred by release may be dismissed under Rule 12(b)(6))