midpage
635 B.R. 568
Bankr. D. Mont.
2022
Read the full case

Background

  • In 2015 nineteen Shoot the Moon entities merged into Shoot the Moon, LLC and promptly filed chapter 11; Jeremiah Foster was later appointed chapter 11 trustee and then liquidating trustee.
  • In 2016 the Trustee sought to sell substantially all estate assets; several secured creditors (including First Interstate Bank and Prairie Mountain Bank/American Bank Center) agreed conditionally via a stipulation that included a broad mutual release of "any and all" known and unknown claims arising before approval.
  • The bankruptcy court approved the sale and incorporated the stipulation (and its broad release) into a final order; the Trustee did not appeal that order.
  • Nearly five years later the Trustee filed an adversary complaint alleging the lenders knew of and participated in a multi-year check‑kiting scheme and that the Trustee’s consent to the release was obtained by fraud (fraudulent concealment / nondisclosure).
  • Defendants moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), arguing the court‑approved release bars the claims and that the complaint fails to plead facts invalidating the release.
  • The bankruptcy court held the complaint alleged only passive nondisclosure, not the affirmative acts Montana law requires to show fraudulent concealment, and therefore the release barred the asserted claims; dismissal was granted with leave to amend.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether the court‑approved release bars Trustee’s claims Trustee says release was procured by fraud and is void, so claims survive Release is broad and final; it bars Trustee’s claims Release bars the claims as pled; dismissal appropriate
Whether defendants’ alleged nondisclosure equals actionable fraud/concealment Trustee: lenders concealed involvement in check‑kiting when negotiating release Defendants: mere failure to volunteer information is not fraud; no affirmative concealment alleged Mere nondisclosure insufficient under Montana law; complaint fails to plead affirmative concealment
Whether a special duty to disclose exists in settlement negotiations ("peculiar knowledge") Trustee: lenders had "peculiar knowledge" creating duty to volunteer facts Defendants: no authority imposes such duty on adversaries; would undermine settlements Court rejects a general duty to volunteer unrequested information in this context
Procedural remedy: dismissal standard and amendment Trustee seeks to proceed or amend Defendants seek dismissal with prejudice Dismissal under Rule 12(b)(6) granted but leave to amend allowed (must plead affirmative acts)

Key Cases Cited

  • Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (pleading must state a plausible claim)
  • Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (plausibility standard for complaints)
  • Wellness Int’l Network, Ltd. v. Sharif, 575 U.S. 665 (bankruptcy litigant may consent to entry of final judgment by the bankruptcy court)
  • Facebook, Inc. v. Pac. Nw. Software, Inc., 640 F.3d 1034 (enforce clear releases between adversaries; parties in equal bargaining positions expected to use discovery)
  • Wolfe v. Flathead Elec. Coop., Inc., 393 Mont. 312 (Montana requires affirmative acts to prove fraudulent concealment)
  • Skilstaf, Inc. v. CVS Caremark Corp., 669 F.3d 1005 (claims barred by release may be dismissed under Rule 12(b)(6))
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: FOSTER v. FIRST INTERSTATE BANK
Court Name: United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Montana
Date Published: Jan 18, 2022
Citations: 635 B.R. 568; 2:21-ap-02005
Docket Number: 2:21-ap-02005
Court Abbreviation: Bankr. D. Mont.
Log In