Force v. Department of Revenue
252 P.3d 306
Or.2011Background
- Estate of Pierson (farm owner) faced Oregon inheritance tax on farm value; Department assessed $26,767 plus penalties and interest.
- Oregon linked state inheritance tax to pre-2001 federal estate tax law via ORS 118.010(2) and ORS 118.100(1).
- Decedent died January 1, 2003; farm valued at about $1.694 million with IRC 2032A farm exemption claimed in federal return.
- IRS later recalculated exemption under pre-2001 law, yielding a zero federal estate tax and zero state death tax credit, but Oregon statutes reference the credit 'allowable' under pre-2001 federal law.
- Tax Court granted summary judgment for the Department, holding Oregon tax liability aligned with pre-2001 federal law; plaintiff appealed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proper interpretation of ORS 118.010(2). | Force contends IRS zero credit controls Oregon tax. | Department argues 'allowable' credit is tied to pre-2001 federal law per ORS 118.007 and context. | Oregon tax liability determined by pre-2001 federal law; Department entitled to judgment. |
| Proper interpretation of ORS 118.100(1) timing. | Tax not due because federal estate tax is not payable under current law. | Timing is fixed to federal tax payable under December 31, 2000 code, per ORS 118.007. | Tax due when federal tax payable under pre-2001 code; IRS audit irrelevant. |
Key Cases Cited
- PGE v. Bureau of Labor and Industries, 317 Or. 606 (Or. 1993) (statutory interpretation principles for Oregon statutes)
- State v. Gaines, 346 Or. 160 (Or. 2009) (interpretation of statutory text in context)
- Morris v. Dept. of Rev., 320 Or. 579 (Or. 1995) (federal tax references in state tax statutes)
- Tharp v. PSRB, 338 Or. 413 (Or. 2005) (interpretation of undefined terms in statutes)
- Stevens v. Czerniak, 336 Or. 392 (Or. 2004) (text should be read in context)
- Lane County v. LCDC, 325 Or. 569 (Or. 1997) (contextual statutory construction)
- Powers v. Quigley, 345 Or. 432 (Or. 2008) (consistency across related statutory provisions)
