History
  • No items yet
midpage
Federal Nat. Mortgage Assn. v. Marcuzzo
289 Neb. 301
| Neb. | 2014
Read the full case

Background

  • Marcuzzos own property in Sarpy County secured by FNMA through a deed of trust after default and sale.
  • FNMA filed forcible entry and detainer in county court against the Marcuzzos seeking possession.
  • The Marcuzzos appeared only to challenge jurisdiction, alleging an underlying district court title action (Case No. CI 12-116).
  • FNMA moved to continue the forcible entry and detainer action until the district court title action was decided; the court granted the continuance.
  • Approximately seven months later, the district court action was dismissed as to FNMA; later evidence of a title dispute was not presented to the county court before final rulings.
  • At a later hearing, the Marcuzzos offered no evidence of a live title dispute; the court issued a writ of restitution in FNMA’s favor.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether county court had jurisdiction to continue Marcuzzo: continuance implied title dispute; jurisdiction divested FNMA: no title dispute evidenced; continuance permissible County court had jurisdiction to continue
Whether county court could enter restitution despite potential title dispute Marcuzzo: ongoing title dispute barred restitution FNMA: title dispute resolved or not present; restitution proper County court could issue restitution
Whether lack of a timely error statement affects review Marcuzzo: need appellate review for plain error only FNMA: jurisdictional analysis remains proper under plain-error standard Plain-error review applied; no merit found

Key Cases Cited

  • Cummins Mgmt. v. Gilroy, 266 Neb. 635 (2003) (title dispute requires dismissal, not suspension when demurrer/plea in abatement resolves it)
  • Pettit v. Black, 12 N.W. 841 (1882) (ancillary authorities on forcible entry and detainer timelines)
  • Intercall, Inc. v. Egenera, Inc., 284 Neb. 801 (2012) (recording requirements for error support in appellate review)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Federal Nat. Mortgage Assn. v. Marcuzzo
Court Name: Nebraska Supreme Court
Date Published: Oct 17, 2014
Citation: 289 Neb. 301
Docket Number: S-13-929
Court Abbreviation: Neb.