midpage
2013 Ohio 351
Ohio Ct. App.
2013

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Plaintiff Jonathan Duck, as administrator of Isaac Duck’s estate, sues James Dennis Cantoni, M.D., and Marietta Memorial Hospital for wrongful death/medical malpractice following Isaac’s death shortly after birth in 2006.
  • Isaac was delivered via emergency cesarean section with Apgar scores of 0 and no heart rate at birth.
  • Cantoni unsuccessfully attempted intubation initially due to dim light, delaying airway management for approximately seven to eight minutes before successful intubation and ventilation.
  • Appellant’s experts Dr. Bove and Dr. Crawford testified Isaac would have had a fifty-percent survival chance if intubated immediately; Crawford later set survival odds at about forty-seven percent given Apgar data.
  • Defendants moved for summary judgment arguing no admissible evidence establishing proximate cause; trial court struck Crawford’s affidavit; court granted summary judgment for Cantoni and the Hospital; Duck appeals.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether summary judgment was proper on loss-of-chance grounds Duck argues loss-of-chance evidence creates a jury question Cantoni/Memorial contend Roberts excludes fifty-fifty survival from loss-of-chance Summary judgment affirmed; loss-of-chance does not apply to fifty-percent survival.
Whether the trial court abused its discretion in striking Dr. Crawford’s affidavit Crawford affidavit clarifies deposition, not contradicts Affidavit contradicted prior testimony without adequate explanation Affirmed; no abuse of discretion in striking affidavit.

Key Cases Cited

  • Roberts v. Ohio Permanente Medical Group, Inc., 76 Ohio St.3d 483 (1996) (loss-of-chance doctrine permits recovery when chance is less than 50%)
  • Cooper v. Sisters of Charity of Cincinnati, Inc., 27 Ohio St.2d 242 (1971) (probability defined; words like maybe/around 50% not enough for probability)
  • Davis v. Guarnieri, 45 Ohio St. 470 (1887) (probability concept referenced in loss-of-chance discussion)
  • McDermott v. Tweel, 151 Ohio App.3d 763 (2003) (limits on loss-of-chance applicability in some contexts)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Duck v. Cantoni
Court Name: Ohio Court of Appeals
Date Published: Jan 29, 2013
Citations: 2013 Ohio 351; 11CA20
Docket Number: 11CA20
Court Abbreviation: Ohio Ct. App.
Log In