Slip Opinion
Sup. Ct. R.I.2010Background
- Davis, as Davco's President and shareholder, sues JT Building for damages and fees, alleging Landlord unreasonably withheld consent to a Lease assignment and seeks strike of the assignment provision and release from the Guaranty.
- JT Building counterclaims that it reasonably withheld consent, that Davco/Davis breached the Lease by an improper assignment prior to consent, and that Davis and Davco remain primarily liable under the Lease and Guaranty; also seeks fees and costs.
- The Lease, dated December 9, 2004, covers a 10-year term for a Quiznos Sub on Premises at 448 Newport Ave., Pawtucket; it requires Landlord consent for assignments, with consent not to be unreasonably withheld, and includes a Guaranty by Davis for Davco's obligations.
- Lease paragraph 12 permits certain assignments to Quiznos Franchising LLC or its affiliates without consent, but a transfer to a duly authorized franchisee requires Landlord's reasonable consent based on financials and guaranty; consent clause states consent shall not relieve Davco of liability.
- Davis sought to sell Davco’s assets to Chois (ChoiS Management, Inc.) leading to an Asset Purchase Agreement in April 2007; Landlord requested Chois’ financials and credit reports, expressing concerns about their ability to meet Lease obligations.
- After reviewing financial statements and security, Landlord refused consent to the asset transfer, prompting an Amendment on August 3, 2007: the Chois acquired Davco’s stock, but Davco remained the Tenant under the Lease; the asset sale did not trigger a Lease assignment under the terms.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Is the Guaranty enforceable after the stock sale? | Davis argues the Guaranty altered by the stock sale relieves him of liability. | JT Building contends Guaranty remains irrevocable and continuing despite the stock sale. | Guaranty remains enforceable; stock sale did not alter Davis's continuing liability. |
| Did Landlord unreasonably withhold consent to the Lease assignment? | Davis contends Landlord's refusal to consent was unreasonable given the proposal and Davis's continued liability. | JT Building argues the Chois’ financials and guaranty justified withholding consent. | Landlord unreasonably withheld consent; financials and guaranty did not justify withholding under the Lease. |
| Did the stock sale constitute a breach of the Assignment and Subletting clause? | Davco/Davis claim no assignment occurred due to stock sale, so no breach occurred. | JT Building contends the stock sale modified the party structure and breached the assignment provisions. | No breach found; stock sale did not implicate the Assignment and Subletting clause as no assignment occurred. |
| Does Davis remain liable as Guarantor after the stock sale? | Davis asserts no continued personal liability due to altered principal-debtor relationship. | JT Building maintains Davco and Davis remain liable under the Guaranty. | Davis remains personally liable; stock sale did not alter the Guaranty’s scope or Davco’s continued obligation. |
| Should either party recover attorney's fees under § 9-1-45 or the contract? | Neither party asserts a statutory basis for fees beyond the contract. | Landlord argues for fees under § 9-1-45 and contract provisions. | Neither party awarded attorney's fees; each bears its own costs. |
Key Cases Cited
- Merrimack Valley Nat. Bank v. Baird, 372 Mass. 721 (Mass. 1977) (strict guaranty construction; terms govern liability)
- Weinsklar Realty Co. v. Dooley, 200 Wis. 412, 228 N.W. 515 (Wis. 1930) (guarantors bound by assignment provisions; liability continues)
- Shepard Land Co. v. Banigan, 36 R.I. 1, 87 A. 531 (R.I. 1913) (material alterations of contract may release guarantor)
- Ringwood Assocs., Ltd. v. Jack's of Route 23, 153 N.J. Super. 294, 379 A.2d 508 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 1977) (lease covenants and assignment; landlord's duties; reasonableness standard)
- Pakwood Indus. v. John Galt Assoc., 219 Ga. App. 527, 466 S.E.2d 226 (Ga. App. 1995) (reasonableness of withholdings based on assignee's financials)