midpage
Slip Opinion
Sup. Ct. R.I.
2010

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Davis, as Davco's President and shareholder, sues JT Building for damages and fees, alleging Landlord unreasonably withheld consent to a Lease assignment and seeks strike of the assignment provision and release from the Guaranty.
  • JT Building counterclaims that it reasonably withheld consent, that Davco/Davis breached the Lease by an improper assignment prior to consent, and that Davis and Davco remain primarily liable under the Lease and Guaranty; also seeks fees and costs.
  • The Lease, dated December 9, 2004, covers a 10-year term for a Quiznos Sub on Premises at 448 Newport Ave., Pawtucket; it requires Landlord consent for assignments, with consent not to be unreasonably withheld, and includes a Guaranty by Davis for Davco's obligations.
  • Lease paragraph 12 permits certain assignments to Quiznos Franchising LLC or its affiliates without consent, but a transfer to a duly authorized franchisee requires Landlord's reasonable consent based on financials and guaranty; consent clause states consent shall not relieve Davco of liability.
  • Davis sought to sell Davco’s assets to Chois (ChoiS Management, Inc.) leading to an Asset Purchase Agreement in April 2007; Landlord requested Chois’ financials and credit reports, expressing concerns about their ability to meet Lease obligations.
  • After reviewing financial statements and security, Landlord refused consent to the asset transfer, prompting an Amendment on August 3, 2007: the Chois acquired Davco’s stock, but Davco remained the Tenant under the Lease; the asset sale did not trigger a Lease assignment under the terms.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Is the Guaranty enforceable after the stock sale? Davis argues the Guaranty altered by the stock sale relieves him of liability. JT Building contends Guaranty remains irrevocable and continuing despite the stock sale. Guaranty remains enforceable; stock sale did not alter Davis's continuing liability.
Did Landlord unreasonably withhold consent to the Lease assignment? Davis contends Landlord's refusal to consent was unreasonable given the proposal and Davis's continued liability. JT Building argues the Chois’ financials and guaranty justified withholding consent. Landlord unreasonably withheld consent; financials and guaranty did not justify withholding under the Lease.
Did the stock sale constitute a breach of the Assignment and Subletting clause? Davco/Davis claim no assignment occurred due to stock sale, so no breach occurred. JT Building contends the stock sale modified the party structure and breached the assignment provisions. No breach found; stock sale did not implicate the Assignment and Subletting clause as no assignment occurred.
Does Davis remain liable as Guarantor after the stock sale? Davis asserts no continued personal liability due to altered principal-debtor relationship. JT Building maintains Davco and Davis remain liable under the Guaranty. Davis remains personally liable; stock sale did not alter the Guaranty’s scope or Davco’s continued obligation.
Should either party recover attorney's fees under § 9-1-45 or the contract? Neither party asserts a statutory basis for fees beyond the contract. Landlord argues for fees under § 9-1-45 and contract provisions. Neither party awarded attorney's fees; each bears its own costs.

Key Cases Cited

  • Merrimack Valley Nat. Bank v. Baird, 372 Mass. 721 (Mass. 1977) (strict guaranty construction; terms govern liability)
  • Weinsklar Realty Co. v. Dooley, 200 Wis. 412, 228 N.W. 515 (Wis. 1930) (guarantors bound by assignment provisions; liability continues)
  • Shepard Land Co. v. Banigan, 36 R.I. 1, 87 A. 531 (R.I. 1913) (material alterations of contract may release guarantor)
  • Ringwood Assocs., Ltd. v. Jack's of Route 23, 153 N.J. Super. 294, 379 A.2d 508 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. 1977) (lease covenants and assignment; landlord's duties; reasonableness standard)
  • Pakwood Indus. v. John Galt Assoc., 219 Ga. App. 527, 466 S.E.2d 226 (Ga. App. 1995) (reasonableness of withholdings based on assignee's financials)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Davis v. Jt Building
Court Name: Superior Court of Rhode Island
Date Published: Nov 5, 2010
Citations: 2010 WL 4551605; C.A. No. PB 07-4683
Docket Number: C.A. No. PB 07-4683
Court Abbreviation: Sup. Ct. R.I.
Log In