164 So. 3d 516
Miss. Ct. App.2015Background
- Davarious Talley (19) was convicted by a Scott County jury of burglary of a dwelling for a December 22, 2012 break-in at Damekia Boone’s home and sentenced to 12 years.
- Stolen items included an Xbox and a GPS; windows were pried open and a locked back door was found unlocked.
- Multiple eyewitnesses (teenagers Prayer Wright, Keshun Chandler, Nikki, and others) testified that they observed Talley near or entering Boone’s house; some testimony described seeing him enter through a window and later exit through the back door.
- Police found Talley in a maroon van with an Xbox and Garmin GPS devices shortly after the incident; Talley denied involvement and testified others committed the burglary.
- On cross-examination, Prayer testified she saw Talley enter through a window but did not personally see him exit; she relayed that others told her they saw him leave. Defense objected and moved to strike that portion as hearsay; the trial court denied the motion. Talley appealed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the trial court erred by refusing to strike testimony that relayed out-of-court statements (hearsay) that Talley exited the house | State: testimony admissible and not outcome-determinative; Prayer directly saw entry and other witnesses corroborated | Talley: the portion saying Prayer heard others tell her he exited was hearsay and should have been stricken | Court: No reversible error — testimony was elicited by Talley’s counsel (so he cannot complain), entry (not exit) is the key element, other witnesses corroborated, any error harmless |
Key Cases Cited
- Osborne v. State, 54 So. 3d 841 (Miss. 2011) (standard for reviewing admission/exclusion of evidence and harmless-error rule)
- Rogers v. State, 85 So. 3d 293 (Miss. 2012) (a defendant cannot complain on appeal about evidence he elicited at trial)
- Fleming v. State, 604 So. 2d 280 (Miss. 1992) (same principle regarding appellate review of evidence elicited by defendant)
