349 Ga. App. 681
Ga. Ct. App.2019Background
- On Sept. 28, 2012, victim Lekeidra Taylor was forced into the back seat of an SUV driven by Kareem Daniels, who took her wallet; Taylor photographed Daniels and his license plate and police later arrested Daniels.
- A jury convicted Daniels of robbery by force; he received a 20-year sentence (5 years confinement, remainder probation); other convictions were set aside or acquitted.
- At trial Taylor testified she left a prior job at Kroger to pursue healthcare work and denied being caught shoplifting; defense sought to impeach her with a written resignation statement indicating misuse of gift cards and an employee discount.
- The trial court excluded the prior written statement as collateral/irrelevant and barred extrinsic evidence under OCGA § 24-6-613(b) and § 24-6-608(b); the court also limited cross-examination about prior misconduct.
- On remand the trial court held an evidentiary hearing on whether the State knowingly elicited false testimony and whether introduction of black-and-white duplicates (rather than original color photos) violated the best-evidence rule; the court denied relief and this appeal followed.
Issues
| Issue | Daniels' Argument | State's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Admission of extrinsic prior inconsistent statement (impeachment) | Trial court erred by forbidding impeachment of Taylor with her Kroger resignation statement | The statement was collateral/irrelevant to case issues and extrinsic evidence was barred | Court affirmed: exclusion was within trial court discretion (collateral matter) |
| 2. Cross-examination about prior bad acts (OCGA § 24-6-608(b)) | Court improperly curtailed cross-examination about misconduct reflected in resignation statement | Court properly exercised discretion to limit inquiry and disallow extrinsic proof of specific acts | Court affirmed: no clear abuse of discretion |
| 3. Prosecutor’s failure to correct allegedly false testimony (due process/Napue claim) | Taylor’s testimony that she left Kroger to pursue healthcare and wasn’t caught shoplifting was false and State failed to correct it | Statements were not shown to be actually false or known false by State; no perjury established; not material | Court affirmed: Daniels failed to show actual falsehood, knowledge, or materiality |
| 4. Admission of black-and-white photographs vs. original color photos (best-evidence) | Admission of B/W duplicates of color photos violated best-evidence rule and was prejudicial | Any error was not plain error because admission did not affect outcome; duplicates are generally admissible | Court affirmed: even assuming error, Daniels failed plain-error prong showing effect on substantial rights |
Key Cases Cited
- Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307 (standard for construing evidence in favor of verdict)
- Hood v. State, 299 Ga. 95 (treatment of OCGA § 24-6-613(b) and collateral-matter doctrine)
- Brewner v. State, 302 Ga. 6 (requirements for admitting extrinsic prior inconsistent statements)
- United States v. Bordeaux, 570 F.3d 1041 (defining collateral matter in impeachment context)
- United States v. Blackwood, 456 F.2d 526 (extrinsic impeachment limited to non-collateral matters)
- Napue v. Illinois, 360 U.S. 264 (prosecutor’s duty to correct false testimony)
- Patch v. State, 337 Ga. App. 233 (four-prong plain-error test for unobjected-to evidentiary rulings)
- Kelly v. State, 290 Ga. 29 (difficulty of satisfying all plain-error prongs)