332 So.3d 1287
Miss.2022Background
- Late-night traffic stop for nonworking tag lights; officer Derek Romero approached a Toyota Camry with driver Martin Burkett and passenger Damian Brown (who initially gave a false name).
- Romero observed a handgun on the passenger-side floorboard behind Brown’s legs and saw Brown slide his foot, moving the gun under the seat.
- Romero opened the car, asked Brown to exit; upon Brown exiting Romero observed two bags of white powder on the passenger seat.
- Brown pointed to the gun, fled before being patted down, and was chased and arrested; officers recovered a Glock 30, 2.11 grams of cocaine, and multiple oxycodone-containing tablets from the passenger side.
- Brown was convicted of three counts of possession of a controlled substance and one count of unlawful possession of a firearm by a convicted felon; he was sentenced as a habitual offender to 24 years, day-for-day.
- On appeal Brown challenged the trial court’s denial of two proposed jury instructions: D-11 (possession—momentary handling language) and D-12 (circumstantial-evidence instruction).
Issues
| Issue | Brown's Argument | State's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether denial of D-11 (possession instruction defining possession as excluding mere momentary handling) was error | D-11 accurately stated law and fit his defense (momentary handling exception) | The court’s granted instruction (S-5) already and better explained constructive possession (dominion, control, awareness) | Denial affirmed — S-5 fairly and more completely covered the law; D-11 was inapplicable given the facts (no mere momentary handling) |
| Whether denial of D-12 (circumstantial-evidence instruction) was error | Entitled to circumstantial-evidence instruction because no eyewitness/confession | Under Nevels such instruction is no longer required/available | Denial affirmed — Nevels eliminated the prior entitlement to a circumstantial-evidence instruction |
Key Cases Cited
- Curry v. State, 249 So. 2d 414 (Miss. 1971) (defines constructive possession: dominion/control plus awareness)
- Nevels v. State, 325 So. 3d 627 (Miss. 2021) (overruled prior rule requiring circumstantial-evidence jury instruction)
- Victory v. State, 83 So. 3d 370 (Miss. 2012) (jury-instruction rulings reviewed for abuse of discretion; instructions read as whole)
- Newell v. State, 49 So. 3d 66 (Miss. 2010) (instructions assessed collectively; no error if they fairly announce the law)
- Rubenstein v. State, 941 So. 2d 735 (Miss. 2006) (instruction-review principles)
- Stringfellow v. State, 595 So. 2d 1320 (Miss. 1992) (older precedent recognizing circumstantial-evidence instruction, later overruled)
- Berry v. State, 652 So. 2d 745 (Miss. 1995) (example of momentary-handling cases distinguished here)
