Slip Opinion
Mass. Super. Ct.Sep 22, 2025Background
- Schap is charged with murder and larceny from a building in connection with Kevin Bergeron’s death around July 7, 2020, with Bergeron’s body found in Marlborough.
- Initial autopsy was inconclusive on cause and manner; later, after Schap’s confession, autopsy concluded homicide by asphyxia due to upper airway obstruction.
- Schap confessed on October 11, 2020, describing detailed acts and providing information not publicized; indictment issued February 11, 2022.
- Schap moved to dismiss under the corroboration rule, arguing it requires corpus delicti evidence beyond the confession; Commonwealth contends death suffices.
- Grand jury evidence included Schap’s statements about striking Bergeron with a weightlifting bar, discovery of weightlifting bars, and a recovered necklace linked to Bergeron.
- Court denied the Motion to Dismiss, finding sufficient corroboration under either interpretation of the rule and noting ample corroborating evidence.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Does corroboration require more than death to convict in a homicide? | Schap argues extra corroboration beyond death is required. | Schap contends the rule needs independent evidence of foul play beyond death. | Sufficient corroboration found under either interpretation; motion denied. |
Key Cases Cited
- Commonwealth v. Forde, 392 Mass. 453 (Mass. 1984) (corroboration rule requires some corroboration beyond confession)
- Commonwealth v. Burgos, 470 Mass. 133 (Mass. 2014) (in homicide, corroboration need only tend to show death)
- Commonwealth v. Manning, 41 Mass. App. Ct. 18 (Mass. App. Ct. 1996) (corpus delicti defined; death may suffice for homicide corroboration)
- Commonwealth v. Weaver, 474 Mass. 787 (Mass. 2016) (rejected broad expansion of corroboration for juveniles)
- Commonwealth v. Leonard, 401 Mass. 470 (Mass. 1988) (concerns limitations on evidentiary corroboration under prior doctrine)
- Commonwealth v. Costello, 411 Mass. 371 (Mass. 1991) (early corroboration concerns in homicide evidence)
- Commonwealth v. Landenburg, 41 Mass. App. Ct. 23 (Mass. App. Ct. 1996) (related corroboration considerations in appellate context)
- Commonwealth v. O’Dell, 392 Mass. 445 (Mass. 1984) (grand jury sufficiency standard; not testing guilt, but probable cause to arrest)
- Commonwealth v. Moran, 453 Mass. 880 (Mass. 2009) (grand jury indictment standards and prosecutorial process)