midpage
218 A.3d 935
Pa. Super. Ct.
2019

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • On October 25, 2016, a police investigation into heroin sales used a confidential informant (CI) who arranged a buy with a seller known as “Flex.”
  • The CI placed recorded/intercepted cell calls with Flex; officers set up surveillance at the agreed meeting location (vacant Weis supermarket parking lot).
  • A silver BMW matching the CI’s description arrived within minutes; the CI identified the driver as Flex. Officers arrested Appellant (Bernard) and, on search incident to arrest, recovered the target cell phone, $245, and 25 glassine bags later tested and confirmed as heroin.
  • At trial the Commonwealth introduced stipulations as to Officer Spathelf’s expected testimony and the forensic lab results; Appellant waived a jury and was tried by the court (bench trial).
  • The court convicted Bernard of attempted delivery, possession with intent to deliver (PWID), criminal use of a communication facility, possession, and paraphernalia; sentencing included consecutive terms and post-sentence proceedings resulted in partial merger but not for attempt and PWID.
  • On appeal Bernard challenged (1) denial of suppression (probable cause from CI) and (2) legality of sentencing/merger of attempt and PWID; appellate court affirmed convictions but vacated the sentence for attempted delivery and remanded for resentencing.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument (Commonwealth) Defendant's Argument (Bernard) Held
Whether seizure/arrest was supported by probable cause based on an unproven CI CI tip corroborated by recorded calls and surveillance; officers independently verified description, timing, and vehicle CI was unreliable and uncorroborated; arrest was warrantless and unlawful so evidence should be suppressed Denied suppression; probable cause existed based on corroboration by intercepted calls, surveillance, CI participation in past deals, and matching vehicle/behavior
Whether convictions for PWID and attempted delivery must merge for sentencing The offenses are legally distinct; Commonwealth proved intent and substantial step toward delivery allowing separate convictions Attempt and PWID arose from same actus reus (possessing drugs and arriving at the meet) so attempt is a lesser-included offense and must merge Convictions affirmed but sentence for attempted delivery vacated because attempt is subsumed by PWID; remanded for resentencing to restructure consecutive terms

Key Cases Cited

  • Commonwealth v. Smith, 164 A.3d 1255 (Pa. Super. 2017) (standard of review for suppression rulings)
  • Commonwealth v. Goldsborough, 31 A.3d 299 (Pa. Super. 2011) (informant tips may support probable cause with corroboration or demonstrated reliability)
  • Commonwealth v. Clark, 28 A.3d 1284 (Pa. 2011) (probable cause from CI depends on veracity, reliability, and basis of knowledge in a commonsense manner)
  • Commonwealth v. Sanchez, 907 A.2d 477 (Pa. 2006) (CI information may suffice with independent police corroboration)
  • Commonwealth v. Manuel, 194 A.3d 1076 (Pa. Super. 2018) (same principle on CI corroboration)
  • Commonwealth v. Calhoun, 52 A.3d 281 (Pa. Super. 2012) (statutory merger under 42 Pa.C.S. § 9765 requires that all elements of one offense be included in the other)
  • Commonwealth v. Roberts, 133 A.3d 759 (Pa. Super. 2016) (elements of PWID: possession plus intent to deliver; factors to infer intent)
  • Commonwealth v. Thur, 906 A.2d 552 (Pa. Super. 2006) (remand for resentencing when vacatur disrupts trial court's sentencing scheme)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Com. v. Bernard, F.
Court Name: Superior Court of Pennsylvania
Date Published: Sep 4, 2019
Citations: 218 A.3d 935; 2019 Pa. Super. 271; 1449 MDA 2018
Docket Number: 1449 MDA 2018
Court Abbreviation: Pa. Super. Ct.
Log In