midpage
740 F. App'x 740
2d Cir.
2018
Read the full case

Background

  • Plaintiff Chris H. (pro se) was held in civil contempt by New York State Supreme Court Justice Tandra L. Dawson for failing to pay for an appraisal required by a court order in ongoing matrimonial litigation.
  • Chris H. was remanded to custody from April 12 to April 14 after the contempt finding.
  • He filed a federal suit against the State of New York and Justice Dawson (official and individual capacities) asserting 25 federal and state-law claims and seeking $20 million.
  • Defendants moved to dismiss; the district court dismissed federal claims for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction (sovereign and judicial immunity) and declined supplemental jurisdiction over state-law claims.
  • The Second Circuit affirmed, holding New York immune under the Eleventh Amendment and Justice Dawson immune under judicial immunity; it upheld dismissal of state claims without prejudice by declining supplemental jurisdiction.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether federal court has subject-matter jurisdiction over damages claims against the State of New York Chris H. sought damages under federal statutes and common-law theories New York asserted Eleventh Amendment sovereign immunity bars damages in federal court Held: Eleventh Amendment bars the damages claims against New York; no waiver or abrogation exists
Whether Justice Dawson (official capacity) can be sued for damages in federal court Chris H. sought damages from Dawson in her official capacity Dawson argued Eleventh Amendment bars official-capacity damages suits Held: Official-capacity damages barred by Eleventh Amendment
Whether Justice Dawson (individual capacity) is immune from damages for presiding over the contempt proceeding Chris H. alleged judicial misconduct and sought damages from Dawson individually Dawson asserted absolute judicial immunity for judicial acts within jurisdiction Held: Judicial immunity applies; individual-capacity damages barred
Whether the district court should retain supplemental jurisdiction over state-law claims after dismissing federal claims Chris H. sought to have state-law claims heard in federal court Defendants urged dismissal of state claims after dismissal of federal claims Held: District court did not abuse discretion in declining supplemental jurisdiction and dismissing state claims

Key Cases Cited

  • Aurecchione v. Schoolman Transp. Sys., Inc., 426 F.3d 635 (2d Cir. 2005) (standard of review for Rule 12(b)(1) jurisdictional dismissals)
  • Makarova v. United States, 201 F.3d 110 (2d Cir. 2000) (definition of lack of statutory or constitutional power to adjudicate)
  • Catzin v. Thank You & Good Luck Corp., 899 F.3d 77 (2d Cir. 2018) (abuse-of-discretion review for supplemental jurisdiction decisions)
  • Dean v. Univ. at Buffalo Sch. of Med. & Biomedical Scis., 804 F.3d 178 (2d Cir. 2015) (Eleventh Amendment principles regarding state immunity)
  • Trotman v. Palisades Interstate Park Comm’n, 557 F.2d 35 (2d Cir. 1977) (New York’s waiver of immunity in Court of Claims but not in federal court)
  • Dube v. State Univ. of N.Y., 900 F.2d 587 (2d Cir. 1990) (§ 1983 does not abrogate state sovereign immunity)
  • Fincher v. State of Fla. Dep’t of Labor & Emp’t Sec. Unemployment Appeals Comm’n, 798 F.2d 1371 (11th Cir. 1986) (Congress did not abrogate state immunity for § 1985 claims)
  • Bliven v. Hunt, 579 F.3d 204 (2d Cir. 2009) (absolute judicial immunity for judicial actions, bad faith or malice insufficient)
  • Huminski v. Corsones, 396 F.3d 53 (2d Cir. 2005) (two-prong test for judicial immunity: judicial nature and subject-matter jurisdiction)
  • Stump v. Sparkman, 435 U.S. 349 (1978) (judicial immunity standards)
  • Mireles v. Waco, 502 U.S. 9 (1991) (limits on judicial immunity: nonjudicial acts or absence of all jurisdiction)
  • Kolari v. New York-Presbyterian Hosp., 455 F.3d 118 (2d Cir. 2006) (when district courts may decline supplemental jurisdiction)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Chris H. v. State
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
Date Published: Oct 29, 2018
Citations: 740 F. App'x 740; 18-21
Docket Number: 18-21
Court Abbreviation: 2d Cir.
Log In