740 F. App'x 740
2d Cir.2018Background
- Plaintiff Chris H. (pro se) was held in civil contempt by New York State Supreme Court Justice Tandra L. Dawson for failing to pay for an appraisal required by a court order in ongoing matrimonial litigation.
- Chris H. was remanded to custody from April 12 to April 14 after the contempt finding.
- He filed a federal suit against the State of New York and Justice Dawson (official and individual capacities) asserting 25 federal and state-law claims and seeking $20 million.
- Defendants moved to dismiss; the district court dismissed federal claims for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction (sovereign and judicial immunity) and declined supplemental jurisdiction over state-law claims.
- The Second Circuit affirmed, holding New York immune under the Eleventh Amendment and Justice Dawson immune under judicial immunity; it upheld dismissal of state claims without prejudice by declining supplemental jurisdiction.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether federal court has subject-matter jurisdiction over damages claims against the State of New York | Chris H. sought damages under federal statutes and common-law theories | New York asserted Eleventh Amendment sovereign immunity bars damages in federal court | Held: Eleventh Amendment bars the damages claims against New York; no waiver or abrogation exists |
| Whether Justice Dawson (official capacity) can be sued for damages in federal court | Chris H. sought damages from Dawson in her official capacity | Dawson argued Eleventh Amendment bars official-capacity damages suits | Held: Official-capacity damages barred by Eleventh Amendment |
| Whether Justice Dawson (individual capacity) is immune from damages for presiding over the contempt proceeding | Chris H. alleged judicial misconduct and sought damages from Dawson individually | Dawson asserted absolute judicial immunity for judicial acts within jurisdiction | Held: Judicial immunity applies; individual-capacity damages barred |
| Whether the district court should retain supplemental jurisdiction over state-law claims after dismissing federal claims | Chris H. sought to have state-law claims heard in federal court | Defendants urged dismissal of state claims after dismissal of federal claims | Held: District court did not abuse discretion in declining supplemental jurisdiction and dismissing state claims |
Key Cases Cited
- Aurecchione v. Schoolman Transp. Sys., Inc., 426 F.3d 635 (2d Cir. 2005) (standard of review for Rule 12(b)(1) jurisdictional dismissals)
- Makarova v. United States, 201 F.3d 110 (2d Cir. 2000) (definition of lack of statutory or constitutional power to adjudicate)
- Catzin v. Thank You & Good Luck Corp., 899 F.3d 77 (2d Cir. 2018) (abuse-of-discretion review for supplemental jurisdiction decisions)
- Dean v. Univ. at Buffalo Sch. of Med. & Biomedical Scis., 804 F.3d 178 (2d Cir. 2015) (Eleventh Amendment principles regarding state immunity)
- Trotman v. Palisades Interstate Park Comm’n, 557 F.2d 35 (2d Cir. 1977) (New York’s waiver of immunity in Court of Claims but not in federal court)
- Dube v. State Univ. of N.Y., 900 F.2d 587 (2d Cir. 1990) (§ 1983 does not abrogate state sovereign immunity)
- Fincher v. State of Fla. Dep’t of Labor & Emp’t Sec. Unemployment Appeals Comm’n, 798 F.2d 1371 (11th Cir. 1986) (Congress did not abrogate state immunity for § 1985 claims)
- Bliven v. Hunt, 579 F.3d 204 (2d Cir. 2009) (absolute judicial immunity for judicial actions, bad faith or malice insufficient)
- Huminski v. Corsones, 396 F.3d 53 (2d Cir. 2005) (two-prong test for judicial immunity: judicial nature and subject-matter jurisdiction)
- Stump v. Sparkman, 435 U.S. 349 (1978) (judicial immunity standards)
- Mireles v. Waco, 502 U.S. 9 (1991) (limits on judicial immunity: nonjudicial acts or absence of all jurisdiction)
- Kolari v. New York-Presbyterian Hosp., 455 F.3d 118 (2d Cir. 2006) (when district courts may decline supplemental jurisdiction)