Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.2019Background
- Pro se plaintiff William C. Carleton sued DOCCS Commissioner Anthony Annucci, Marcy Correctional Facility Sergeant Leddick, Lieutenant Cook, and a John/Jane Doe under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and disability statutes.
- Defendants moved for summary judgment asserting failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Plaintiff did not timely respond to the motion despite warnings.
- Magistrate Judge Thérèse Wiley Dancks granted an extension, issued an Order and Report-Recommendation finding exhaustion had not occurred, and recommended dismissal with prejudice.
- DOCCS grievance supervisors (Erin Pfendler and Rachel Seguin) declared no grievance or appeal records by Carleton against the named defendants during his incarceration.
- The magistrate found exhaustion was impossible now because the grievance deadline had passed and Carleton offered no evidence the grievance process was unavailable.
- District Judge Mae A. D'Agostino adopted the Report-Recommendation, granted summary judgment for defendants, and ordered the case closed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether Carleton exhausted administrative remedies for Eighth Amendment claims against Leddick and Cook | Carleton did not present evidence of filed grievances or appeals | No grievances or appeals exist in facility records; exhaustion mandatory under PLRA | Defendants proved failure to exhaust; claims dismissed for lack of exhaustion |
| Whether Carleton exhausted ADA and Rehabilitation Act claims against Annucci | Carleton did not produce record of grievances or appeals | DOCCS internal grievance records show no appeals by Carleton | Claims dismissed for failure to exhaust |
| Whether dismissal should be with prejudice | Carleton offered no evidence that grievance process was unavailable or that he could still exhaust | Defendants contend deadlines passed and grievance process is not available now | Court held failure to exhaust is incurable; dismissal with prejudice appropriate |
| Effect of plaintiff's failure to object to magistrate's report | N/A (no objections filed) | Magistrate provided explicit notice that failure to object waives appellate review | Court reviewed for clear error and adopted the Report-Recommendation; objections waived for appeal |
Key Cases Cited
- Jones v. Bock, 549 U.S. 199 (PLRA requires exhaustion of administrative remedies)
- Cephas v. Nash, 328 F.3d 98 (failure to object to magistrate report waives challenge on appeal)
- Chambers v. TRM Copy Ctrs. Corp., 43 F.3d 29 (summary judgment standard and drawing inferences for non-moving party)
- Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, 477 U.S. 242 (standard for determining genuine issue of material fact)
- Frank v. Johnson, 968 F.2d 298 (pro se litigant must receive notice that failure to object waives review)
- Small v. Secretary of Health & Human Servs., 892 F.2d 15 (notice requirement for pro se litigants regarding waiver)
- Roldan v. Racette, 984 F.2d 85 (cited in notice about consequences of failing to object to report)