midpage
Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.
2019

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Pro se plaintiff William C. Carleton sued DOCCS Commissioner Anthony Annucci, Marcy Correctional Facility Sergeant Leddick, Lieutenant Cook, and a John/Jane Doe under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and disability statutes.
  • Defendants moved for summary judgment asserting failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Plaintiff did not timely respond to the motion despite warnings.
  • Magistrate Judge Thérèse Wiley Dancks granted an extension, issued an Order and Report-Recommendation finding exhaustion had not occurred, and recommended dismissal with prejudice.
  • DOCCS grievance supervisors (Erin Pfendler and Rachel Seguin) declared no grievance or appeal records by Carleton against the named defendants during his incarceration.
  • The magistrate found exhaustion was impossible now because the grievance deadline had passed and Carleton offered no evidence the grievance process was unavailable.
  • District Judge Mae A. D'Agostino adopted the Report-Recommendation, granted summary judgment for defendants, and ordered the case closed.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether Carleton exhausted administrative remedies for Eighth Amendment claims against Leddick and Cook Carleton did not present evidence of filed grievances or appeals No grievances or appeals exist in facility records; exhaustion mandatory under PLRA Defendants proved failure to exhaust; claims dismissed for lack of exhaustion
Whether Carleton exhausted ADA and Rehabilitation Act claims against Annucci Carleton did not produce record of grievances or appeals DOCCS internal grievance records show no appeals by Carleton Claims dismissed for failure to exhaust
Whether dismissal should be with prejudice Carleton offered no evidence that grievance process was unavailable or that he could still exhaust Defendants contend deadlines passed and grievance process is not available now Court held failure to exhaust is incurable; dismissal with prejudice appropriate
Effect of plaintiff's failure to object to magistrate's report N/A (no objections filed) Magistrate provided explicit notice that failure to object waives appellate review Court reviewed for clear error and adopted the Report-Recommendation; objections waived for appeal

Key Cases Cited

  • Jones v. Bock, 549 U.S. 199 (PLRA requires exhaustion of administrative remedies)
  • Cephas v. Nash, 328 F.3d 98 (failure to object to magistrate report waives challenge on appeal)
  • Chambers v. TRM Copy Ctrs. Corp., 43 F.3d 29 (summary judgment standard and drawing inferences for non-moving party)
  • Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, 477 U.S. 242 (standard for determining genuine issue of material fact)
  • Frank v. Johnson, 968 F.2d 298 (pro se litigant must receive notice that failure to object waives review)
  • Small v. Secretary of Health & Human Servs., 892 F.2d 15 (notice requirement for pro se litigants regarding waiver)
  • Roldan v. Racette, 984 F.2d 85 (cited in notice about consequences of failing to object to report)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Carleton v. Annucci
Court Name: District Court, N.D. New York
Date Published: Feb 4, 2019
Citations: 2019 WL 422530; 9:17-cv-00245
Docket Number: 9:17-cv-00245
Court Abbreviation: N.D.N.Y.
Log In