Slip Opinion
S.D. Ohio2021Background
- Plaintiff Lawrence Burfitt, proceeding pro se, sued SOCF employees alleging First Amendment retaliation and Eighth Amendment excessive-force / deliberate-indifference claims against Brion Lawless (personal capacity) and Lts. Haywood and Bowers (individual capacities).
- Court previously dismissed claims against two defendants and official-capacity claims against Lawless, Haywood, and Bowers; remaining individual-capacity claims proceeded.
- Administrative record: Burfitt filed an informal complaint (initially to the wrong department), a Use of Force statement, and several grievances; grievances were denied and not appealed. Burfitt alleges defendants interfered with his ability to exhaust by confiscating legal work, moving his cell repeatedly, denying medication, and intimidating him.
- Defendants moved for summary judgment arguing failure to exhaust PLRA remedies and moved to strike portions of Burfitt’s declaration; they also moved to dismiss based on an alleged voluntary withdrawal by Burfitt (and alternatively sought an extension of the dispositive-motion deadline).
- The Magistrate Judge recommended denying summary judgment and the motion to strike, finding a genuine factual dispute over whether officials’ actions rendered the grievance process unavailable; the District Court adopted the R&R, denied summary judgment and dismissal, denied the motion to strike, and granted an extension of the dispositive-motion deadline.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether summary judgment should be granted for failure to exhaust PLRA remedies | Burfitt says he attempted to exhaust but was prevented by officials’ interference and intimidation | Defendants say Burfitt filed numerous grievances later, so he exhausted remedies and was not deterred | Denied: factual dispute exists whether remedies were available; summary judgment inappropriate |
| Whether alleged harassment/retaliation made administrative remedies "unavailable" | Burfitt contends cell moves, property seizures, lost legal work, threats, and withheld meds deterred exhaustion | Defendants argue later grievance activity shows no deterrence and that Burfitt must show each defendant prevented exhaustion | Held for Burfitt on the record: court adopts Magistrate Judge that a reasonable jury could find officials’ actions would deter a person of ordinary firmness; defendants bear burden to prove no interference |
| Motion to strike portions of Burfitt's declaration | Burfitt relies on his declaration to describe interference and intimidation | Defendants argued parts were immaterial, scandalous, or lacked personal knowledge | Denied: striking is inappropriate where material relates to the controversy and factual disputes exist |
| Motion to dismiss based on alleged voluntary withdrawal; alternative request for extension | Burfitt opposes dismissal and asks case to proceed | Defendants point to a filing in another court suggesting withdrawal; alternatively requested more time for dispositive motions | Dismissal denied (Burfitt did not voluntarily abandon here); extension of dispositive-motion deadline granted |
Key Cases Cited
- Ross v. Blake, 136 S. Ct. 1850 (2016) (a prisoner must exhaust only available administrative remedies; unavailability excuses exhaustion)
- Jones v. Bock, 549 U.S. 199 (2007) (failure to exhaust is an affirmative defense; plaintiffs need not plead exhaustion)
- Does 8–10 v. Snyder, 945 F.3d 951 (6th Cir. 2019) (tests whether officials’ actions would deter a person of ordinary firmness from pursuing grievances)
- Bell v. Johnson, 308 F.3d 594 (6th Cir. 2002) (adverse acts like confiscating legal materials and property can satisfy the deterrence test)
- Thaddeus-X v. Blatter, 175 F.3d 378 (6th Cir. 1999) (retaliation must produce adverse action that would deter a person of ordinary firmness)
- Surles v. Andison, 678 F.3d 452 (6th Cir. 2012) (ability to file some grievances does not preclude a finding that other relevant grievances were effectively blocked)
- Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317 (1986) (summary-judgment burden-shifting principles)
- Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242 (1986) (standard for genuine dispute of material fact at summary judgment)