midpage
349 A.3d 1130
Del.
2025

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • On May 9, 2023, Thaddeus Blackman was shot and killed outside a Wilmington convenience store; surveillance video showed a masked shooter moving through nearby streets and entering 31 E. 23rd St. shortly after the shooting.
  • Police identified witness Darnella Spady from surveillance; at a station interview she identified the shooter as “Gunner” and picked Kevin Berry from a photo lineup; she described prior interactions and alleged threats by the shooter.
  • At Berry’s bench trial (Berry waived jury), Spady was uncooperative: she attempted to invoke the Fifth, then repeatedly testified she could not remember the shooting or her police statement, citing heroin use, though she acknowledged she was the person in the recorded interview and that she had been handcuffed when brought to the station.
  • The State moved to admit Spady’s videotaped station interview under 11 Del. C. § 3507; the trial court found the statement voluntary, concluded the State met Section 3507’s foundation under McCrary, and admitted the tape over Berry’s objection.
  • The court convicted Berry of first-degree murder and related weapons offenses and sentenced him to life plus ten years; Berry appealed, arguing McCrary should be overturned and that the State failed to meet Section 3507’s foundation for admitting Spady’s statement.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument (State) Defendant's Argument (Berry) Held
Whether this Court should overrule McCrary v. State McCrary correctly clarifies Section 3507's "touching-on" foundation; stare decisis should control McCrary departed from longstanding precedent requiring substantive in-court testimony on events, and should be reconsidered Court declined to revisit McCrary; no urgent reason or clear error shown; stare decisis applies
Whether Section 3507 foundation was met for admitting Spady’s out-of-court statement Calling the declarant and asking questions about events and the statement (including showing video) satisfied the touching-on requirement; voluntariness was found The State did not elicit substantive testimony that Spady witnessed the killing or that her statement was truthful; memory lapse deprived Berry of meaningful cross-examination Trial court did not abuse discretion; State sufficiently touched on events (video confirmation that Spady was present) and voluntariness was found
Whether a declarant’s claimed total memory loss can bar Section 3507 admission because of Confrontation Clause concerns Memory lapses do not automatically bar admission; opportunity for cross-examination and observation of demeanor suffice under Fensterer and McCrary A total, genuine memory loss can make cross-examination a hollow exercise and threaten confrontation rights; McCrary enables admission despite that risk Majority: memory lapse here did not deny effective cross-examination; counsel cross-examined and court evaluated credibility. Dissent: would've excluded as abuse of discretion
Whether the trial court’s voluntariness finding was adequate and preserved trial court discretion Voluntariness is a separate factual threshold trial court must make and did so here; McCrary does not eliminate voluntariness review McCrary effectively lets prosecutors control admissibility, making voluntariness the only remaining check and insufficient to protect defendants Court affirmed voluntariness finding (unchallenged on appeal) and held trial court retains discretion to assess voluntariness and credibility

Key Cases Cited

  • McCrary v. State, 290 A.3d 442 (Del. 2023) (clarified Section 3507 "touching-on" foundation: prosecutor need not elicit substantive testimony, only open topics for cross-examination)
  • Keys v. State, 337 A.2d 18 (Del. 1975) (originally required production and direct examination of declarant touching on events and the out-of-court statement)
  • Ray v. State, 587 A.2d 439 (Del. 1991) (Section 3507 requires cross-examination on content and truthfulness of prior statement)
  • Johnson v. State, 338 A.2d 124 (Del. 1975) (admission of prior statements not barred by limited courtroom recall; emphasized careful, case-by-case use)
  • Wyche v. State, 113 A.3d 162 (Del. 2015) (trial court must find voluntariness before admitting a prior statement under § 3507)
  • Delaware v. Fensterer, 474 U.S. 15 (U.S. 1985) (Confrontation Clause satisfied where witness testifies under oath and is subject to cross-examination despite memory lapse)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Berry v. State
Court Name: Supreme Court of Delaware
Date Published: Sep 15, 2025
Citations: 349 A.3d 1130; 2025 WL 2639971; 357, 2024
Docket Number: 357, 2024
Court Abbreviation: Del.
Log In