Slip Opinion
E.D. La.2019Background
- Denise Badgerow initially sued in federal court (Civil Action 17-9492) alleging employment discrimination, Equal Pay Act, breach of contract, and whistleblower claims; FINRA arbitration was held and the arbitrators dismissed all claims against Ameriprise and the individual principals with prejudice.
- The federal court confirmed the FINRA arbitration award in favor of Ameriprise and rejected Badgerow’s fraud challenge to the award.
- Badgerow later filed state-court suits (Lafourche and Orleans Parishes) seeking to vacate the arbitration award under Louisiana law; the Orleans action was removed to federal court by defendants Greg Walters, Thomas Meyer, and Ray Trosclair (the Principals) and became Civil Action 19-10353.
- Badgerow moved to remand the removed action to state court, arguing her petition to vacate asserted only state-law issues; the Principals moved to confirm the arbitration award in federal court and invoked federal-question jurisdiction via the “look-through” approach from Vaden.
- The court assumed, for jurisdictional purposes, that the Fifth Circuit would apply Vaden’s look-through approach to FAA §10 vacatur actions, determined the award involved federal-law claims (joint-employer federal claims), and concluded federal-question jurisdiction existed despite Badgerow’s artful pleading.
- The court denied remand, granted the Principals’ motion to confirm the arbitration award, and entered final judgment dismissing the §10 vacatur action.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether federal court has subject-matter jurisdiction over a removed state petition to vacate an arbitration award | Badgerow: petition invokes only state law (La. R.S. §9:4210) and thus lacks a federal question; artful pleading should control | Principals: Vaden look-through permits examining underlying arbitration to find federal questions because the arbitration included federal claims | Court: Jurisdiction exists; denied remand because the arbitration award encompassed federal claims so federal-question jurisdiction applies |
| Whether Vaden’s look-through approach applies to §10 vacatur petitions | Badgerow: Vaden should not be extended; §10 lacks §4’s text | Principals: Vaden should apply to avoid stripping federal issues from petitions to vacate | Court: Assumed Fifth Circuit would apply Vaden to §10 and proceeded on that basis |
| Whether Badgerow’s fraud challenge to the arbitration award is a live attack requiring remand | Badgerow: renewed fraud allegations justify vacatur | Principals: Fraud challenge already adjudicated and rejected | Court: Fraud challenge was previously considered and rejected; no relitigation; award confirmed |
| Whether court should rely on FAA language in state pleading | Badgerow: avoided invoking FAA in state filing; argues this forecloses federal jurisdiction | Principals: FAA coverage in arbitration agreements and federal issues in the award support federal jurisdiction | Court: FAA confers no jurisdiction on its own, but presence of federal issues in the arbitration award supplies jurisdiction despite Badgerow’s pleading choices |
Key Cases Cited
- Vaden v. Discover Bank, 556 U.S. 49 (establishes the “look-through” approach for FAA §4 petitions to determine federal-question jurisdiction)
- Goldman v. Citigroup Global Mkts., Inc., 834 F.3d 242 (3d Cir.) (declines to extend Vaden to §10 vacatur petitions; emphasizes textual differences)
- Ortiz-Espinosa v. BBVA Securities, Inc., 852 F.3d 36 (1st Cir.) (extends Vaden look-through rationale to §10 vacatur petitions)
- Doscher v. Sea Port Grp. Securities, LLC, 832 F.3d 372 (2d Cir.) (applies Vaden principles to §10 vacatur actions)
- Syngenta Crop Prot., Inc. v. Henson, 567 U.S. 28 (clarifies that the All Writs Act does not confer subject-matter jurisdiction)
- Venable v. La. Workers’ Comp. Corp., 740 F.3d 937 (5th Cir.) (discusses when federal issues are substantial enough to confer jurisdiction)