midpage
Slip Opinion
E.D. La.
2019
Read the full case

Background

  • Denise Badgerow initially sued in federal court (Civil Action 17-9492) alleging employment discrimination, Equal Pay Act, breach of contract, and whistleblower claims; FINRA arbitration was held and the arbitrators dismissed all claims against Ameriprise and the individual principals with prejudice.
  • The federal court confirmed the FINRA arbitration award in favor of Ameriprise and rejected Badgerow’s fraud challenge to the award.
  • Badgerow later filed state-court suits (Lafourche and Orleans Parishes) seeking to vacate the arbitration award under Louisiana law; the Orleans action was removed to federal court by defendants Greg Walters, Thomas Meyer, and Ray Trosclair (the Principals) and became Civil Action 19-10353.
  • Badgerow moved to remand the removed action to state court, arguing her petition to vacate asserted only state-law issues; the Principals moved to confirm the arbitration award in federal court and invoked federal-question jurisdiction via the “look-through” approach from Vaden.
  • The court assumed, for jurisdictional purposes, that the Fifth Circuit would apply Vaden’s look-through approach to FAA §10 vacatur actions, determined the award involved federal-law claims (joint-employer federal claims), and concluded federal-question jurisdiction existed despite Badgerow’s artful pleading.
  • The court denied remand, granted the Principals’ motion to confirm the arbitration award, and entered final judgment dismissing the §10 vacatur action.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether federal court has subject-matter jurisdiction over a removed state petition to vacate an arbitration award Badgerow: petition invokes only state law (La. R.S. §9:4210) and thus lacks a federal question; artful pleading should control Principals: Vaden look-through permits examining underlying arbitration to find federal questions because the arbitration included federal claims Court: Jurisdiction exists; denied remand because the arbitration award encompassed federal claims so federal-question jurisdiction applies
Whether Vaden’s look-through approach applies to §10 vacatur petitions Badgerow: Vaden should not be extended; §10 lacks §4’s text Principals: Vaden should apply to avoid stripping federal issues from petitions to vacate Court: Assumed Fifth Circuit would apply Vaden to §10 and proceeded on that basis
Whether Badgerow’s fraud challenge to the arbitration award is a live attack requiring remand Badgerow: renewed fraud allegations justify vacatur Principals: Fraud challenge already adjudicated and rejected Court: Fraud challenge was previously considered and rejected; no relitigation; award confirmed
Whether court should rely on FAA language in state pleading Badgerow: avoided invoking FAA in state filing; argues this forecloses federal jurisdiction Principals: FAA coverage in arbitration agreements and federal issues in the award support federal jurisdiction Court: FAA confers no jurisdiction on its own, but presence of federal issues in the arbitration award supplies jurisdiction despite Badgerow’s pleading choices

Key Cases Cited

  • Vaden v. Discover Bank, 556 U.S. 49 (establishes the “look-through” approach for FAA §4 petitions to determine federal-question jurisdiction)
  • Goldman v. Citigroup Global Mkts., Inc., 834 F.3d 242 (3d Cir.) (declines to extend Vaden to §10 vacatur petitions; emphasizes textual differences)
  • Ortiz-Espinosa v. BBVA Securities, Inc., 852 F.3d 36 (1st Cir.) (extends Vaden look-through rationale to §10 vacatur petitions)
  • Doscher v. Sea Port Grp. Securities, LLC, 832 F.3d 372 (2d Cir.) (applies Vaden principles to §10 vacatur actions)
  • Syngenta Crop Prot., Inc. v. Henson, 567 U.S. 28 (clarifies that the All Writs Act does not confer subject-matter jurisdiction)
  • Venable v. La. Workers’ Comp. Corp., 740 F.3d 937 (5th Cir.) (discusses when federal issues are substantial enough to confer jurisdiction)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Badgerow v. Walters
Court Name: District Court, E.D. Louisiana
Date Published: Jun 26, 2019
Citations: 2019 WL 2611127; 2:19-cv-10353
Docket Number: 2:19-cv-10353
Court Abbreviation: E.D. La.
Log In