Adcock v. COM., DEPT. OF SOCIAL SERVICES
719 S.E.2d 304
| Va. | 2011Background
- Divorce decree in Alexandria 1966 required Adcock to pay $30/week for three children until majority; youngest emancipated 1982, ending obligation.
- Houchens seeks to collect arrears from 1967–1982 despite termination date.
- DCSE enforcement sought in 2006; circuit court allowed collection including arrears and interest with total $73,629.10.
- Adcock raised statute-of-limitations defense under Code § 8.01-251(A); argued arrears were judgments beyond 20 years.
- Court of Appeals affirmed circuit court; Adcock appealed to Supreme Court of Virginia.
- Supreme Court reverses, holding that each missed payment becomes a judgment by operation of law and is subject to the 20-year limit.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Does § 8.01-251(A) bar collection of past due arrears from an ongoing support decree? | Houchens: statute applies only to liquidated judgments, not ongoing obligations. | Adcock: arrears are judgments created by operation of law and within 20-year limit. | Yes; § 8.01-251(A) applies to judgments, including those arising from unpaid ongoing orders. |
| Do installments become judgments on the date due if unpaid, triggering the 20-year period? | Houchens: not applicable; ongoing obligation not a liquidated judgment. | Adcock: unpaid installments become judgments when due. | Yes; each unpaid installment becomes a judgment on its due date. |
Key Cases Cited
- Bennett v. Commonwealth ex rel. Waters, 15 Va.App. 135, 422 S.E.2d 458 (1992) (distinguishes ongoing unliquidated obligation from liquidated judgments for limitations)
- Cofer v. Cofer, 205 Va. 834, 140 S.E.2d 663 (1965) (payments become vested and cannot be modified once due)
- Hammers v. Hammers, 216 Va. 30, 216 S.E.2d 20 (1975) (ongoing support orders may be enforced and become judgments when due)
- Eaton v. Davis, 176 Va. 330, 10 S.E.2d 893 (1940) (principles on ongoing support and judgments)
- Mozley v. Prestwould Bld. of Dirs., 264 Va. 549, 570 S.E.2d 817 (2002) (text on statutory interpretation of plain terms)
