History
  • No items yet
midpage
Abel & Sons Concrete, LLC v. Juhnke
295 Ga. 150
| Ga. | 2014
Read the full case

Background

  • Ramirez, a Tri-State employee, entered an agreement with Joyce Juhnke to continue Tri-State and repay purchase of the business and equipment after owner DuWayne Juhnke’s death.
  • Ramirez later formed Abel & Sons Concrete, LLC and used Tri-State’s equipment without paying for it.
  • Appellees sued Ramirez, Abel & Sons, and Dollar Concrete Construction for conversion, unjust enrichment, and breach; no injunctive relief sought initially.
  • In 2013, cross-motions for summary judgment were denied; the trial court issued an interlocutory injunction directing equipment be moved, not yet owned by Dollar, with shared storage costs, and restricting use.
  • Appellants did not attend the June 6 hearing; the order granting equitable relief was issued without proper notice to them; the case was remanded with instructions to provide proper notice and an evidentiary hearing if a new injunction is needed.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Were Appellants given proper notice before the interlocutory injunction? Appellees contend notice satisfied via summary-judgment hearing. Appellants claim no notice that injunction could follow the hearing. No proper notice; injunction vacated.
Did the trial court abuse its discretion by issuing equitable relief without clear ownership proceedings? Ownership dispute existed, but no equitable relief was raised in filings. Court could issue injunction if necessary to preserve property. Abuse of discretion; remand with notice and hearing if needed.

Key Cases Cited

  • Smith v. Guest Pond Club, Inc., 277 Ga. 143 (Ga. 2003) (fair warning required for interlocutory relief)
  • Consortium Mgmt. Co. v. Mutual America Corp., 246 Ga. 346 (Ga. 1980) (notice may be established by hearing participation)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Abel & Sons Concrete, LLC v. Juhnke
Court Name: Supreme Court of Georgia
Date Published: May 5, 2014
Citation: 295 Ga. 150
Docket Number: S14A0157
Court Abbreviation: Ga.